Reading that, I feel like I need a promotion. I'd like to move p from orc to eldritch abomination, my alien geometries too horrible to fully perceive or comprehend. I think it would explain a lot.
Lucy: ... I... Oh wow. I'm pretty sure if you set your novels in a real location with a real living history, you should respect those familiar with the city when they take issue with what reads as apparent whitewashing of extremely serious issues.
JB: I did respect them, actually. Up until the "fuck you Jim Butcher" part. I take that back. Up until the part where they play the racist card. :)
Lucy: Sir, please don't bring up the tone argument. They have valid complaints. Don't delegitimize them for daring to be angry. What you did read as racist. It may not be fair to call *you* a racist, but they have the right to level that to the text. You are a white man. You do not get to tell a marginalized group what they can and can't be offended by.
JB: OH, okay. Now I get it. I'm white, so I need to have that kind of hate thrown my way and STFU.
Comments 9
Reply
Reply
Reply
OH, okay. Now I get it. I'm white, so I need to have that kind of hate thrown my way and STFU.
Seeking Avalon has thoughts:
http://seeking-avalon.blogspot.com/2011/07/fuck-you-jim-butcher.html
Reply
Reply
Lucy: ... I... Oh wow. I'm pretty sure if you set your novels in a real location with a real living history, you should respect those familiar with the city when they take issue with what reads as apparent whitewashing of extremely serious issues.
JB: I did respect them, actually. Up until the "fuck you Jim Butcher" part. I take that back. Up until the part where they play the racist card. :)
Lucy: Sir, please don't bring up the tone argument. They have valid complaints. Don't delegitimize them for daring to be angry. What you did read as racist. It may not be fair to call *you* a racist, but they have the right to level that to the text. You are a white man. You do not get to tell a marginalized group what they can and can't be offended by.
JB: OH, okay. Now I get it. I'm white, so I need to have that kind of hate thrown my way and STFU.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment