Of this and that...

Apr 10, 2007 22:02

Oh, God. People at TWOP, just SHUT UP!

Yes, yes, JRM is not over six feet tall and Henry VIII was. OMG! Ohnoez. Horrors. OMG, not historically accurate. BLAH. I am one of ten people who didn’t love Rome (it was good but didn’t grab me) and am one of ten people loving The Tudors. Anyway, nothing wrong with thinking it’s boring, slow-moving, ( Read more... )

rain, tudors, rome

Leave a comment

Comments 25

autumn_yaar April 11 2007, 02:06:49 UTC
WHAT NO I'LL BE IN EGYPT

Reply

meganbmoore April 11 2007, 02:19:40 UTC
I'd pity you, but you'll be in Egypt. So I shall be jealous instead.

Reply

autumn_yaar April 11 2007, 02:31:34 UTC
But I've already been to Egypt! I WANT TO SEE BI RIP OFF HIS SHIRT IN PERSON TOOOO

Ah, the world is so unfair. T_T

Reply

meganbmoore April 11 2007, 02:36:09 UTC
see, the whole "second trip" part just kills the sympathy altogether...

*would be a sad, sad fangirly type person and hunting for ricketty old Emersons' if she ever went to Egypt*

(urm...the Emerson's are the family in Elizabeth Peters's Amelia Peabody(Emerson) mystery series...if you haven't read the books)

Reply


smartylibrarian April 11 2007, 02:12:55 UTC
Rain with no shirt..... *swoon*

I can't wait! We'll have to keep a watch for when tickets go on sale.

Reply

dangermousie April 11 2007, 02:42:42 UTC
I can't wait! We'll have to keep a watch for when tickets go on sale.

Definitely. So, did you finish Full House?

Reply


meganbmoore April 11 2007, 02:17:20 UTC
This is why I only go to TWOP for chuckles over how people can be stupid(like when they go on for eternity about there being no homosexual themes in Agatha Christie's books and then use any version of "A Murder is Announced" as an argument when it has the most canon homosexual couple Christie ever wrote)

The sex scenes in Rome are a large part of why I haven't checked it out...and frankly, any time I see Cleopatra and things like"orgy" my instinct is to go "no thank you" because, historically(propoganda wrtings aside) the only men she was ever linked to were her husbands(and not at the same time) under the laws of her country.

YAY! to getting VM S2.

What's waitress about?

Reply

dangermousie April 11 2007, 02:44:18 UTC
TWOP people are scary.

Rome is not historically accurate AND pretentious about it. While Tudors has a laid back attitude about it that endears me to it.

Waitress is about a small town waitress who is planning to leave her icky husband but discovers she is preggers. She also falls in love with the town doc, NF. It's an indie...

Reply

meganbmoore April 11 2007, 02:49:02 UTC
I'm odd about my historical shows and movies myself...I'm just as likely to love something for being historically accurate as I am to hate it, and the same is true for blatantly inaccurate. It's all about how true they are to history as they set it.

Reply


morwen_peredhil April 11 2007, 02:41:06 UTC
I'm not going near the TWoP boards for The Tudors. I'm doing just fine on balancing my annoyance at its rape of history with my gleeful love of its soft-pr0ny soap-operatic glory, and I don't need the denizens of TWoP harshing that!

I think the super-cranky people need to look at nekkid screen caps until they forget what they were raging about. At least that works for me. :-P

Reply

dangermousie April 11 2007, 02:45:24 UTC
I think the super-cranky people need to look at nekkid screen caps until they forget what they were raging about. At least that works for me. :-P

Now I want to get all rageful so you's soothe me with screencaps.

Reply


janlake83 April 11 2007, 03:33:04 UTC
yeah apparently in RL i am the only in my circle of friends and family loving the tudors... why cause it's meant to be entertaining not historically accurate... i am sadly waiting for the third eps...

and yeah i am waiting to get some money and will be buying season 1 and 2 of VM cause sad to say the third season wasn't worth watching.. although i knew they shoot the college scenes in sdsu (san diego state university) and i live in sd but like wrong to say that one of the pa's was a friend.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

dangermousie April 11 2007, 04:45:41 UTC
They are not mutually exclusive, but they don't have to match up. I have yet to see a really historical movie. I used to be really upset about that stuff (one of my double majors in college was history) but I realized that it was pointless: it was never going to be accurate. Now I view most historical fiction as an AU, an enjoyable or not as the case may be, but the inaccuracies, short of something truly staggering don't bug me if I like it otherwise...

Reply

(The comment has been removed)


Leave a comment

Up