The Worst Lost Episode Ever tournament: FUBAR Four

[cynthia_arrow]

Thanks to all who voted in the last poll! We're getting down to the wire now. This poll will determine our two finalists, the episodes that will compete head-to-head for Worst Lost Episode Ever

Comments

[emiliglia]

I don't know if I can pick between Eggtown and Expose. They're both horrific!

[cynthia_arrow]

Maybe I'm weird, but I just don't get what's so horrible about Eggtown. (Of course, it's possible it was so lame and ridiculous I've blocked it out, lol.)

[emiliglia]

I think Expose was lulzy with the bad (and had Billy Dee Williams!) whereas Eggtown was just bad. The whole Kate and a baby thing and being drawn on to think she has Sawyer's kid and her being all "I hate babies!" but then she has Aaron was just...bad.

[eponine119]

gah, how do I decide between Fire + Water and Stranger in a Strange Land? On one hand, boring Charlie. On the other hand, Bai Ling.

Poor Expose. It was lame but then to be so hated...

This has been so fun.

[cynthia_arrow]

The thing about Expose seems to be the attitude each person had in approaching it. I expected it to be something it wasn't, and I was disappointed. But all my friends who watched it without taking it a bit seriously thought it was good silly fun. *shrugs*

The Incident, on the other hand, wasn't so much a flawed episode--some exciting, cool things did happen, if you like the more recent time-travel story arcs--as it was he vehicle for two crazy fucking twists of the whole series's plot, one of them based on a story arc that everyone has hated since it started (the triangle/quadrangle).

They're two different kinds of bad. Depends on how you look at it, whether you're going for a silly, useless standalone episode or a stupidly damaging storyline.

[jenthegypsy]

I'm so sorry Stranger and Fire are in the same bracket - both sucked the worst and I wasn't ready to have to choose between them!!

Great poll, btw. ♥