Comments | cumberbatchfans: The Reichenbach Fall Discussion Post.

dancy_dreamer in cumberbatchfans

The Reichenbach Fall Discussion Post.

Jan 15, 2012 20:46

No shiny graphic I'm afraid. I may add one in later if I can distract myself from Golden Globe excitement enough. I am sorry I missed last week, real life shock kinda stole me away. Not sure if people are actually using these are not but hey just in case:

But here is your
The Reichenbach Fall Discussion Post.

There will be spoilers in the ( Read more... )

!discussion post, tv: sherlock

Comments 16

lady_t_220 January 15 2012, 23:03:03 UTC

I want to say something coherent but I can't, I'm far too busy flailing.
Also, really impressed by Steve Thompson's writing this episode. I know when it was originally announced he was taking this story there was a little bit of doubt considering there are a lot of people with a lot of feelings with about TBB, but I think he did an incredible job this time.
Also, I think Martin just about killed me at the end. D:

kanameyu January 15 2012, 23:08:20 UTC

Yeah! I didn't really enjoy the second episode of the first season and was a bit doubtful but it ended up being fantastic. The first scene killed me though.

e_witness January 16 2012, 18:29:33 UTC

I'd just like to echo that Steve Thompson proved to be a spectacular writer.

ascendant_angel January 15 2012, 23:27:57 UTC

I have no reached a coherent state yet, that I suspect will not come quickly

I have just this to say:

John - Sob
Molly- You are made of awesome I'm sorry I ever doubted this.

smittenfancy January 16 2012, 01:04:30 UTC

1. Molly was totally in on it.
2. I need several quaaludes.

What do you think the subject is.... wtravler304 January 16 2012, 01:49:08 UTC

Ok I am dying here. My computer is not letting me get to any of the sites that have posted the episode and of course I will have to wait till May to actually see it in the States. UHHHHH!

Re: What do you think the subject is.... mallyns January 16 2012, 02:35:25 UTC

If you have a blue ray player you can order it from Amazon UK. It will be out on the 23rd of Jan.

No need to wait until May.

Re: What do you think the subject is.... kremlindusk January 16 2012, 06:11:13 UTC

Is the Blu-ray region-free?

Re: What do you think the subject is.... mallyns January 16 2012, 06:16:08 UTC

Yup. Plus it might be cheaper than when it comes out in the US. It cost me about $28.

Thread 7

Mind=blown ext_921830 January 16 2012, 09:11:23 UTC

Well, I was just sitting there for an hour and a half after the show finished trying to figure out what happened and searching Twitter for theories. Molly? Some sort of mask that Moriarty used to convince the little girl Sherlock was the kidnapper? That HOUND drug to change John's perception of what he saw?

All the actors were fantastic, and Martin went above and beyond in the last few scenes.

But I do think they should have left Sherlock dead till season 3 - much more of an emotional punch.

I'm a bit concerned that they've already done all the really famous cases - there's not much to build up to once you've already had Holmes' "death" and reappearance. Erm...John's wedding, which in the canon would have already taken place?? And has anyone thought John's character arc suffered in this series? He doesn't even seem to be a practicing doctor anymore, he's just Sherlock's bff.

Fantastic series, a brilliant follow-up to the first season, and that last half hour was some of the tensest, best written and most satisfying telly I've

Re: Mind=blown mariole January 16 2012, 18:04:34 UTC

I loved this also. Spectacular show ( ... )