Since I'm reediting this story, I'm just going to migrate it over here. That way everything will (hopefully) be in one place. Apologies for the resulting deluge!
Um, what's your policy on concrit? :O Yes, no, in private only?
Anyway, this was my first time reading it, and I definitely enjoyed it. :) Luke hearing creepy voices, the screaming and everything was written pretty well. I also think you got Jade's voice down perfectly.
Hahha. I got into a HUGE debate a couple of weeks back with a girl who refused to accept concrit (even though there were so many people telling her her story needed work).
Anyway, I guess my main concern is the jumping POV. For the most part, you're writing in third-person limited, Luke's POV, so when there's a paragraph in the middle of that describing Guy's thoughts I get thrown out of the loop. Guy's POV is okay at the ending, because it's clearly separate. However, the scene where Luke is trying to ease the pain in his wrist has a random Guy POV that forced me to stop to re-read and make sure I got it right. (I kind of noticed this habit in your Vesperia fics too).
Hmm, I've never really thought about that before. I'm not entirely sure I can do anything about it either. o_o;; I think I like getting into the characters' heads a bit too much for my own good. Probably what attracted me to fanfiction in the first place, reading stuff from different viewpoints? Among other things. *cough* But I'll try to keep it in mind for future stuff? :D;;;
Comments 16
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Anyway, this was my first time reading it, and I definitely enjoyed it. :) Luke hearing creepy voices, the screaming and everything was written pretty well. I also think you got Jade's voice down perfectly.
Reply
Reply
Anyway, I guess my main concern is the jumping POV. For the most part, you're writing in third-person limited, Luke's POV, so when there's a paragraph in the middle of that describing Guy's thoughts I get thrown out of the loop. Guy's POV is okay at the ending, because it's clearly separate. However, the scene where Luke is trying to ease the pain in his wrist has a random Guy POV that forced me to stop to re-read and make sure I got it right. (I kind of noticed this habit in your Vesperia fics too).
Reply
Hmm, I've never really thought about that before. I'm not entirely sure I can do anything about it either. o_o;; I think I like getting into the characters' heads a bit too much for my own good. Probably what attracted me to fanfiction in the first place, reading stuff from different viewpoints? Among other things. *cough* But I'll try to keep it in mind for future stuff? :D;;;
Reply
Leave a comment