Comments | cinderbella333: DW Fic: Timeless Dreams

cinderbella333

DW Fic: Timeless Dreams

Jan 15, 2011 14:54

Title: Timeless Dreams

by MuseDePandora (see: Master List of Fanfics)

Disclaimer: Doctor Who belongs to various persons and corporations that are not me or associated with me. This piece of fanfiction is written with the admiration and respect for the original work. I claim no ownership of Doctor Who's creations. No profit is made from this material ( Read more... )

genre: romance, fic: timeless dreams, au, prompt, fandom: doctor who, pairing: river/doctor, ficathon, fanfiction, challenge

Comments 73

promethia_tenk January 16 2011, 00:22:31 UTC

*stares* I . . .

*gestures* *sighs* *gestures*

. . .

*smiles*

*thinks* *breathes a bit* . . .

*hums*

Yes, *nods* that's . . . that's so, then. Good.

promethia_tenk January 16 2011, 01:48:09 UTC

And upon reading again:

*gestures* . . . .

/wistful

cinderbella333 January 16 2011, 20:36:43 UTC

I'm complimented that you like my story so much as to re-read it! Also, it was wonderful to see your reaction. I'm thrilled that you enjoyed it so much. Thank you for leaving me feedback!

scarab_dynasty January 18 2011, 21:46:51 UTC

*points at promethia_tenk* What she said.

<333

Thread 5

owlsie January 16 2011, 01:26:36 UTC

That was incredible.
I wish I could say something that even approached how I feel about it.

cinderbella333 January 16 2011, 20:39:09 UTC

Thank you! I'm very happy that you feel so strongly about my story. That makes me feel great.

mewiet January 16 2011, 06:00:30 UTC

You remember that first time you went to the water park and stood on trembling, goose pimpled knees at the mouth of that ginormous water slide, your veins rushing with skittish energy, yet knowing it's too late to back out now, and then you hop onto the inner tube and shriek as you fly down the loop, half mad as a hatter and the other half already knowing you want to do it again and you're not even midway through yet?

Yeah, that's how I felt reading this. I don't know how to put it any other way. And I'm sorry, I know that doesn't really give you any true feedback nor legitimate justice to the masterpiece you just let me absorb, but I hope a feeling is better than nothing at all.

I don't know how you got all of that from one photograph, but thank you.

Thank you.

cinderbella333 January 16 2011, 20:41:47 UTC

Wow, the paragraph you wrote, likening reading my story to the thrill of a ginormous water-slide was a joy to read. The fact that it was such an experience for you, I'm completely flattered and beyond happy. That was fantastic feedback. Thank you so much!

elisi January 16 2011, 08:58:40 UTC

I was sent here by Promethia, who insisted that this was the greatest Doctor/River fic ever.

I think she was right.

cinderbella333 January 16 2011, 20:45:55 UTC

It's so nice to hear that my story was worthy of recommendation (thank you, Promethia!). I am a bit overwhelmed - but joyfully so- by such praise. Doctor/River has some really amazing work out there by amazing authors. I'm flattered to even be considered in such company. Thank you very much for reading and leaving me such a lovely comment.

elisi January 16 2011, 20:55:29 UTC

Oh I'll be back with more coherent praise, once I've managed the art of being coherent re. this story. Also I'm going to pimp it to the seven corners of LJ... tomorrow. (When I will have time.)

Also, this is the icon that I once mentioned that I one day hoped to get! (If you remember?) I tried my best to condense all my Doctor/River 'shipping into it, although there's a sad lack of water. But it's implied in 'time'.

(This is me rambling. Sorry. Fic still too awesome to get to grips with.)

cinderbella333 January 17 2011, 02:56:24 UTC

I really appreciate that you're planning on recommending this to others! Thank you. I'm really thrilled that you like my story that much.

And you know, I had considered remarking on your icon at first but I seem to ALWAYS remark on your icons since you have so many really good ones. I was worried that you'd get annoyed with that. But I do really adore this icon. I love the color and the word choice and the scene choices. Beautiful!

Thread 5

angearia January 17 2011, 22:10:54 UTC

This was beautiful. My favorite bit was how you related the Doctor's delight at not knowing why the waltz was named the waltz, then connected it to his delight with the mystery of River Song. She's his waltz, the dance he knows not why or what.

Beautiful. ♥

cinderbella333 January 19 2011, 04:28:42 UTC

Thank you! I'm really glad you enjoyed my story. Also, the connections you drew between the waltz and the Doctor's relationship with River Song hadn't occurred to me before. I love it when readers help me see my own writing in a new light. I guess as writers, we do a lot of work on a subconscious level too. Thanks again for reading and leaving me such thoughtful feedback.