Round 7: challenge 2, results

[ch4ndler]

Unfortunately we have to say bye to one wonderful icon maker...

Comments

[nalazhar]

can I get #4

[ch4ndler]

+ good cropping
+ great color

[shadowsong_13]

Thanks for Mod's Choice! May I have the comments for 6 please? :)

[ch4ndler]

+ I like the coloring of it. it is very bright and contrast... The icon is smooth great. And i'm loving the text, which is in the right place
- little blurry

[midsummerly]

comments for #1 please :)

i'll try to make the banners asap, but it also might take a while.

[ch4ndler]

+ /
- coloring looks too unnatural, the background is distracting takes away from the image

[midsummerly]

could you please give me posting access so i can post the banners? that would be wonderful :)

[ch4ndler]

oh sorry, you had it with your previous nickname. I'll fix it now

[russian_hotness]

can i get #3?

[ch4ndler]

- The coloring is a little too dark and its a little oversaturated making Phoebe a little too orange looking
- colour is too yellow, the border doesn't suit the icon
- I think that the color of the border doesn't match here. and it looks simple, I guess with this borders.... maybe the use of some texture could fix it...
- Colouring too dark, border doesn't match
+ great coloring
+ /

[ch4ndler]

- The light coloring on her face has made the left side a little pixilated. Also, the text texture overlay on the left is a little distratcing
- colouring is too red and wrong use of textures
- the picture quality looks bad, a bit blurry
- not sharpened enough
- needs more contrast