Comments | chlims: Round 6, challenge 8, results

ch4ndler in chlims

Round 6, challenge 8, results

Jun 03, 2009 19:08

Unfortunately we have to say bye to one wonderful icon maker...

( Results + Tally )

round 6, results

Comments 6

lonekitty June 3 2009, 17:56:24 UTC

o.O i didn't expect that. thanx.
could i see the comments for #1?

ch4ndler June 3 2009, 21:30:13 UTC

- The close cropping and the use of texture don't compliment the icon
+ /
+ nice coloring and crop

secret_vision June 3 2009, 20:57:52 UTC

Oh I loved your icon Nada, I think the texture use is very original :)

Can I have comments for 3?

ch4ndler June 3 2009, 21:31:37 UTC

+ nice background texture and nice coloring
- the icon is a little blurry
+ Lovely concept. The candles were incorporated well into the background and suits the image of the three

nalazhar June 4 2009, 06:09:51 UTC

Can I have #2 :D ..

ch4ndler June 4 2009, 15:05:14 UTC

- Lovely use of textures, but the crop of the image was too far back and therefore it is hard to see the image of the three
+ Lovely use of texture
- you can bearely see the picture
- while very creative, the image is too far away to see clearly