Leave a comment

Comments 19

thismaz November 22 2009, 12:37:07 UTC
What a sneaky-clever explanation for the use of the reset button that had everybody so up in arms. *g*
Thank you. I enjoyed that.

Reply

catbird_tales November 22 2009, 19:26:46 UTC
Rule #1 in Camelot: When something suspicious is going on, magic is always afoot.

Also, "sneaky-clever" might just be the best compliment ever.

Thank you!

Reply


magog_83 November 22 2009, 16:11:34 UTC
THANK YOU for writing this. I started off intrigued, then my smile just got bigger as I kept reading because this is such a fantastic explanation for the bizarre character shifts we've seen this series, and at the same time it doesn't just ignore things - Arthur really does feel something for Gwen, he DID treat Merlin badly (and he knows it).

Brilliant work!!! Thanks :)

Reply

catbird_tales November 22 2009, 19:39:40 UTC
I was frustrated by the first half of Series 2 mainly because Arthur's personality seemed to have been redefined as "whatever the plot required," rather than continuing the complexities of Series 1. This bothered me enough that I decided to examine how Series 1 Arthur would react to the events of Series 2 and this fic was the result.

Reply


x_etincelle November 22 2009, 22:47:40 UTC
Oh, that was excellent. This makes me slightly less peeved about prat!Arthur in series 2, though he seems to be returning to normal in recent episodes. Brilliant story. I'm mem'ing this. (: ♥

Reply

catbird_tales November 22 2009, 23:44:23 UTC
Thank you. I feel as well that the Series 1 M/A dynamic has been restored to its former depths in the past two episodes (2x08 and 2x09.) It actually makes the ending feel a bit prescient weirdly.

Let's pretend I intended that. :)

Reply


emeraldsword March 22 2010, 20:16:39 UTC
I was sure I commented the last time I read this, but unless you have posted this elsewhere then I guess I didn't, sorry :s

With shoddy cleaning, deplorable footwork, and courageous poison-drinking (and how had Arthur ever forgotten that?) all at his disposal, I love this last sentence, it made me laugh out loud, and I love the way the rest of the fic unfolds. It makes good sense of a lot of oddities in season 2, and deals with the aftermath of the questing beast very nicely, good job.

Reply

catbird_tales March 23 2010, 21:09:00 UTC
Set your mind at ease, sweetheart: you did comment over at merlin_flashfic, but thank you for taking the time to comment again! Your words were the one bright spot in an otherwise miserable start-of-the-week Monday.

Reply


tucuxi July 29 2010, 13:39:20 UTC
[Here via merlin_finders]

I found this a very interesting potential take on Arthur's reversion in S2, and I liked the mirrored behavior you brought to our attention. :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up