Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

May 11, 2004 21:20

I have officially finished the book. For the 7th time? I haven't read it since August. Gah! It's still wonderful. However, my extensive reading on the HP characters (not just slash) has left me thinking about it and analyzing it. Granted, I know that some of the things have been said before. Ok, I'm sure, that somewhere at sometime, someone has ( Read more... )

books 2004, fandom, hp

Leave a comment

Comments 2

stellahobbit May 12 2004, 02:10:59 UTC
With regards to your points -

#3 - I don't believe that Snape would ever forgive Lupin for what happened to him at the Shrieking Shack. Perhaps it was the fact that Lupin never apoligised enough, or because he was part of the Mauraders and found it funny (even though he didn't supposedly know it was going to happen). They were a bunch of bullies after all.

#10 We're missing a huge part of the final picture - book 7 better be 1000 pages to satisfy us all :-)

#11 Once again, Snape and Sirius have too much negative history; that's why I can't believe any Snape/Sirius or Snape/Lupin pairing (I don't care how angry or bitter they are. And Lupin might be a nice man, but he's never been nice to Snape. I can't remember why Snape starts making Wolfsbane Potion for him though - did Dumbledore make him?)

#12 Now that's a pairing I can believe in ( ... )

Reply

byandby May 12 2004, 17:42:09 UTC
#3 & #11 Yeah, I think that there is too much negative history as well. I still think we're missing something though....

#10 book 7 better be 1000 pages to satisfy us all :-) Unfortunately, I've heard that it's going to be short, more like the first 3 books (and, I'm sorry, but, no, not as long as the 3 books combined ;). Personally, I wish she would tell stories like Terry Prachett and the Discworld Series - create a universe and just keep writing stories about everyone and everything.

*Looking for a Discworld novel *

#12 Yum..I do like that pairing, but you know what's better. Sirius, Remus and Harry. Oh yeah, baby ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up