Least Favorite Icons 6 - Too much negative space and the font is too blurry. 13 - Texture overlays caused the icon's contrast look muddy. 17 - The icon is over-sharpened making it look pixelated.
Favorite Icon 7 - Very nice cropping and contrast. 16 - The sharpening and cropping were handled very well.
wow, thanks for letting me sneak in. I won't be that late in the future.
Least Favorite Icons #6 - I like the idea, but maybe a grey texture background and a more interesting font could have made this dull icon more exciting. #1 - unfortunately, the quality and sharpening of the icon just makes it too hard to see what's really going on.also, more contrast could be good. #8 - the scratchy texture takes away from the clarity of the skin and the eye and the brush/text is awkwardly placed.
Favorite Icon #2 - just gorgeous composition and negative space. #10 - nice cropping and brightening.
Least Favorite Icons 05 - there some oversharpening, specially on her hair, and while the text use is interesting, there's no relation (that I can see) to the icon. 12 - interesting crop, but it's a bit dark and the coice of texture/brushes seems a bit random (is that a hand?) 14 - the contrast is not very well handled, the pic lost very much detail and is pixellated in parts.
Favorite Icon 15 - the big eyes are in focus, looking very cute, and good contrast. 4 - interesting crop and "coloring" # - reason
Least Favorite Icons #01 - The colouring's too bland and slightly more contrast would have helped. Also, the crop is too spaced out and un-concentrated which made the icon lack a proper focus. #05 - The text is too bright, cumbersome, and unnecessary. The empty space at the top is really well-balanced though! #13 - The textures are well-used but the tiny text on the side is unnecessary and tips the side of the icon weirdly. It gives the icon a boxed-up look which doesn't seem to work with the image.
Favorite Icon #03 - Nice use of text and space! Good balance on the grays and texture use. #16 - Great use of crop and interesting focus here!
Comments 10
6 - Too much negative space and the font is too blurry.
13 - Texture overlays caused the icon's contrast look muddy.
17 - The icon is over-sharpened making it look pixelated.
Favorite Icon
7 - Very nice cropping and contrast.
16 - The sharpening and cropping were handled very well.
Reply
Least Favorite Icons
#6 - I like the idea, but maybe a grey texture background and a more interesting font could have made this dull icon more exciting.
#1 - unfortunately, the quality and sharpening of the icon just makes it too hard to see what's really going on.also, more contrast could be good.
#8 - the scratchy texture takes away from the clarity of the skin and the eye and the brush/text is awkwardly placed.
Favorite Icon
#2 - just gorgeous composition and negative space.
#10 - nice cropping and brightening.
Reply
05 - there some oversharpening, specially on her hair, and while the text use is interesting, there's no relation (that I can see) to the icon.
12 - interesting crop, but it's a bit dark and the coice of texture/brushes seems a bit random (is that a hand?)
14 - the contrast is not very well handled, the pic lost very much detail and is pixellated in parts.
Favorite Icon
15 - the big eyes are in focus, looking very cute, and good contrast.
4 - interesting crop and "coloring"
# - reason
Reply
#01 - The colouring's too bland and slightly more contrast would have helped. Also, the crop is too spaced out and un-concentrated which made the icon lack a proper focus.
#05 - The text is too bright, cumbersome, and unnecessary. The empty space at the top is really well-balanced though!
#13 - The textures are well-used but the tiny text on the side is unnecessary and tips the side of the icon weirdly. It gives the icon a boxed-up look which doesn't seem to work with the image.
Favorite Icon
#03 - Nice use of text and space! Good balance on the grays and texture use.
#16 - Great use of crop and interesting focus here!
Reply
winners
Reply
Leave a comment