Leave a comment

Comments 7

endearest October 31 2009, 19:17:57 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
##6 - the crop is a little off with her being only a wee bit to the left, it chops off her hair: would be improved centralized. The image quality also appears poor/grainy, it kinda looks sharpened then smoothed?

Favorite Icon
##1 - well placed text & use of space.

Reply


gerryswenchie November 1 2009, 01:37:16 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
#01 - image mixed with background texture makes the icon look blurry,text is hard to see and almost swamps the image.

Favorite Icon
#03 - nice crop,nice positioning in icon,in short - simple but good looking

Reply


hermionesparkle November 1 2009, 05:04:17 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
#6 - the skin looks over sharpened and a bit deformed in the cheeks, lips, & right eye areas.

Favorite Icon
#3 - simple but nicely done. the center crop draws your attention & the border blends in well with the white negative space.

Reply


setentpet November 1 2009, 13:42:34 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
6# - Her skin appears a little blotchy and pixilated.

Favorite Icon
#3 - Very clean and clear icon.

Reply


immortalje November 1 2009, 20:36:46 UTC
This is so difficult and I've been rotating between which icon to vote off. It's so hard to decide what's personal taste and what's wrong (and wondering if I'm being too nitpicky)... and to put it into objective words. (I hope I managed that)

Least Favorite Icons
#5 - The crop itself is nice enough, but the icon could have used something to help with the focus on the group - maybe making the surrounding area darker/the group lighter.

Favorite Icon
#3 - Nice crop and use of borders!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up