This episode didn't have Lee in it so Boppy's meta will be short for once.
Hee, I thought the same thing as I started typing my reaction post. "So I have to write about everyone EXCEPT Lee, well, I guess I can try..."
I like this episode the more that I think about it. I liked it fine to begin with anyway, but after some time to dwell even more on it, I'm just really glad that the show addressed these issues because the class structure and conflict is really integral to their everyday lives and their future as a society. Could there have been a bit more build-up to these class struggles? Yes. But it's not like it's *completely* out of the blue, since inequalities have been mentioned in small amounts since Season 1.
I'm not saying that his 'farming' background was a complete act, but I do imagine he exaggerated the case. He's a chameleon--he will say or do whatever he needs to to survive, and that's why he's so fascinating. I loved that bit with Baltar, and you're dead on when you say he's a chameleon. Back in the day, he turned
( ... )
Yes, it was very very hard to focus without Lee. *sympathetic frownies*
I agree--sure, there could have been a bit more build up on the class struggles, but I'm still glad they tackled it. Besides, I'm kind of used to the sci-fi model of thematically isolated eps. In Star Trek, the class struggle would have come completely out of the blue, or actually wouldn't have ever been mentioned at all. ;-)
One of the things I liked most about Gaius in this episode was the way it demonstrated his social/political genius. Love him or hate him, you can't deny he's got the smarts--at multiple levels. And that's fascinating to watch.
I like Union Chief Tyrol. *g* And I like how the Union just dissipated when everyone returned to the Fleet, as if, with Baltar and the Cylons gone, there was no need for it anymore. How untrue!
I do get the feeling that he'd been duly elected on New Caprica and Roslin just returned his office to him by officially recognizing the union. But I could be wrong.
And of course Baltar would seize on the Voice of the People opportunity. What other chance does he have to get out of his mess? He's crafty, that one. *g*
Oh good, I'm glad you defended him. He's my partner's favourite character but I've never got into him myself. But I know many people are fond of him, so it helps to hear from those that appreciate him.
Baltar is so sneaky! I can't wait to see how the rest of the season plays out...
(I'm about to head off to staff conference, so if I suddenly stop replying to you, that's why! *g*)
Comments 14
Hee, I thought the same thing as I started typing my reaction post. "So I have to write about everyone EXCEPT Lee, well, I guess I can try..."
I like this episode the more that I think about it. I liked it fine to begin with anyway, but after some time to dwell even more on it, I'm just really glad that the show addressed these issues because the class structure and conflict is really integral to their everyday lives and their future as a society. Could there have been a bit more build-up to these class struggles? Yes. But it's not like it's *completely* out of the blue, since inequalities have been mentioned in small amounts since Season 1.
I'm not saying that his 'farming' background was a complete act, but I do imagine he exaggerated the case. He's a chameleon--he will say or do whatever he needs to to survive, and that's why he's so fascinating.
I loved that bit with Baltar, and you're dead on when you say he's a chameleon. Back in the day, he turned ( ... )
Reply
I agree--sure, there could have been a bit more build up on the class struggles, but I'm still glad they tackled it. Besides, I'm kind of used to the sci-fi model of thematically isolated eps. In Star Trek, the class struggle would have come completely out of the blue, or actually wouldn't have ever been mentioned at all. ;-)
One of the things I liked most about Gaius in this episode was the way it demonstrated his social/political genius. Love him or hate him, you can't deny he's got the smarts--at multiple levels. And that's fascinating to watch.
Reply
I do get the feeling that he'd been duly elected on New Caprica and Roslin just returned his office to him by officially recognizing the union. But I could be wrong.
And of course Baltar would seize on the Voice of the People opportunity. What other chance does he have to get out of his mess? He's crafty, that one. *g*
Reply
Baltar is so sneaky! I can't wait to see how the rest of the season plays out...
(I'm about to head off to staff conference, so if I suddenly stop replying to you, that's why! *g*)
Reply
Baltar is so sneaky! I can't wait to see how the rest of the season plays out...
*rubs hands in glee and waits for Trial of Baltar*
And don't worry about a timely or any response. I'm *quite* on top of my flist, as you can see. *embarrassed grin*
Reply
Leave a comment