Leave a comment

Comments 10

vertfonce December 16 2009, 00:22:48 UTC
Well it makes sense that they wouldn't tell you what happens. I mean, the only good thing about those movies was Jack Sparrow, so if you know in advance what happens to him, why bother seeing the movie? At least if I'd known before, I wouldn't have seen it.
It does sound like a terrible book though.

Reply

lone_she_wolf December 16 2009, 00:26:39 UTC
A novelization is usually the whole adaptation of the film. This was the first time where the ending was cut out to not 'spoil it.' If it wasn't going to be the whole story I would like to have been warned because I feel cheated and would have waited for the 'extended book.' If they were afraid of giving away the ending they should have released the whole book after the film release and no version of the book before the film. This was just a sneaky way to get extra money out of the fans.

Reply

vertfonce December 16 2009, 00:41:05 UTC
Okay, I understand what you're saying. That is pretty bad.
But I wouldn't expect any better from them.

Reply

lone_she_wolf December 16 2009, 00:50:14 UTC
Never trust Disney, eh?

Reply


natureboy87 December 16 2009, 05:00:36 UTC
A bad book for a bad movie...imagine that.

Reply

lone_she_wolf December 16 2009, 05:45:44 UTC
It wasn't just a bad story, it was a bad transfer from film to book.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

lone_she_wolf December 17 2009, 03:53:06 UTC
It would probably insult second graders.

Reply


lillongdogwuvr December 17 2009, 06:07:51 UTC
aaah the Boovie. The worst books I've ever read have been boovies. One was even a BV, a book based on the 24 tv series. it was so horrible i left it in london, where i finished reading it.

Reply

lone_she_wolf December 17 2009, 06:20:01 UTC
Soem books based on shows and films aren't bad.

A good cross polination is Doctor Who: Human Nature. This was a novel based on the TV show character. The novel was years later made into an actual episode... the novel was better.

Reply

lillongdogwuvr December 17 2009, 22:32:21 UTC
oh that sounds good! ive been trying to get into doctor who at the request of my dad and some good friends, and maybe a book would help!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up