The historical background on this is both interesting and disturbing. Both Christians and Moslems have some religious restrictions on what they can do with money (e.g. not charge interest), which the Jews never had. So when "good Christians" needed to borrow money, they'd go to the Jews. Then when either the Jews grew rich enough on this that the local rulers saw a chance for gold, or religious fervor swept the land, the Jews would be accused of heresy for allowing this and be persecuted (and their assets probably confiscated). Thus the stereotype of being greedy accountants.
As for stingy, I would venture a guess that they seemed that way because they didn't spend their money on the flambouyancy that was otherwise common through the ages.
I seem to remember something one of my professors said as an aside about the 'big nose' thing having to deal with certain era's portrayals of evil in paintings.
Anyone evil- demons, the devil, etc-- is usually portrayed with a large nose b/c there are few eras in Christianity's rule where a large nose is considered lovely. The outsides _must_ reflect the insides for most of these eras, so if you were ugly-- bulging eyes, large nose, high hairline-- you were evil. So Jews were portrayed with large noses in paintings/woodcuts/sketches as propaganda to help show how evil the moneylenders were.
This sounds good... but could be a load of crapola. It was a history class... So 50/50 chance.
Honestly, I sort of think it's funny, especially the change counter! He probably thinks it's funny, too, and feels like it's a sort of "in-joke" between them. Being able to laugh at the stereotypes of your own ethnicity (both true and untrue) is a virtue.
I'm Native American, and my boyfriend jokingly tells me to "get back to the reservation where I came from", etc., all the time. It's not a big deal.
Comments 65
Reply
Reply
As for stingy, I would venture a guess that they seemed that way because they didn't spend their money on the flambouyancy that was otherwise common through the ages.
Dunno about the noses.
Reply
Anyone evil- demons, the devil, etc-- is usually portrayed with a large nose b/c there are few eras in Christianity's rule where a large nose is considered lovely. The outsides _must_ reflect the insides for most of these eras, so if you were ugly-- bulging eyes, large nose, high hairline-- you were evil. So Jews were portrayed with large noses in paintings/woodcuts/sketches as propaganda to help show how evil the moneylenders were.
This sounds good... but could be a load of crapola. It was a history class... So 50/50 chance.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
I'm Native American, and my boyfriend jokingly tells me to "get back to the reservation where I came from", etc., all the time. It's not a big deal.
Reply
And ftr, my husband is NA as well, and I'd not dare to say that to him, because that's fucked up.
It may not be a big deal to you, and that's fine, but it's a big deal to her, and not right either way.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment