lesser quality 01 - There's some oversharpening (like on her clothes and mouth), the texture seems extraneous and the coloring is a bit dark, dull, and too red on her face, not very flattering. 06 - The icon is just a tad too blurry, and the execution of crop makes her face appear too large. The coloring is a bit red too, specially on her nose (looks like she has a sunburn)
favorite 07 - Great contrast, cropping and background
lesser quality ##4 - the crop hasn't really left a focal point beyond the writing on her shirt, the lil' bits of eyes at the top look odd. It also is a bit blurry & lacking contrast. ##1 - the texture used adds nothing to the icon + the crop is a bit uninteresing, perhaps a central focus would've worked better?
favorite ##5 - great strong contrast + sharpening.
VOTING FORM: lesser quality 1 - Billie's skin tone seems very blotchy and the cyan highlights maker her look a little sickly. The black stripe/texture makes the image look a little dirty. 6 - Her skin seems rough and blotchy, the pink tones are just a little unbalanced with the brighter light pink highlights on her cheeks and forehead. The coloring and tones could just be a little richer and darker.
lesser quality #1 - the texture on the side gives the icon an unbalanced look #3 - the icon is a bit cluttered, there's a lot going on, the addition of the second billie at the top seems unnecessary, she's so faint and small that it begs the question why it's been done. simply extending the background would have looked really great and turned the icon into something i could have voted for for favourite.
favorite #7 - this looks fantastic. really, really fantastic. i love the negative space and the centre placement of billie, great contrast with the b&w, too.
Comments 10
3 - The use of texture distracts from Billie.
1 - The use of texture mutes the coloring to Billie.
favorite
7
Reply
01 - There's some oversharpening (like on her clothes and mouth), the texture seems extraneous and the coloring is a bit dark, dull, and too red on her face, not very flattering.
06 - The icon is just a tad too blurry, and the execution of crop makes her face appear too large. The coloring is a bit red too, specially on her nose (looks like she has a sunburn)
favorite
07 - Great contrast, cropping and background
Reply
##4 - the crop hasn't really left a focal point beyond the writing on her shirt, the lil' bits of eyes at the top look odd. It also is a bit blurry & lacking contrast.
##1 - the texture used adds nothing to the icon + the crop is a bit uninteresing, perhaps a central focus would've worked better?
favorite
##5 - great strong contrast + sharpening.
Reply
VOTING FORM:
lesser quality
1 - Billie's skin tone seems very blotchy and the cyan highlights maker her look a little sickly. The black stripe/texture makes the image look a little dirty.
6 - Her skin seems rough and blotchy, the pink tones are just a little unbalanced with the brighter light pink highlights on her cheeks and forehead. The coloring and tones could just be a little richer and darker.
favorite
5
Reply
#1 - the texture on the side gives the icon an unbalanced look
#3 - the icon is a bit cluttered, there's a lot going on, the addition of the second billie at the top seems unnecessary, she's so faint and small that it begs the question why it's been done. simply extending the background would have looked really great and turned the icon into something i could have voted for for favourite.
favorite
#7 - this looks fantastic. really, really fantastic. i love the negative space and the centre placement of billie, great contrast with the b&w, too.
Reply
Leave a comment