Leave a comment

Comments 25

bitty November 13 2006, 02:25:14 UTC
Well, at least everyone now has a shopping list for you for the holidays.

Reply


hrafn November 13 2006, 02:27:43 UTC
"Do Androids Dream . . ." is a book; or at least the one I read was. It's possible that it started out as a novella or some other sort of shorter form, in a collection.

Reply


sweetmmeblue November 13 2006, 02:39:37 UTC
Wow, I've only read 15 of those because many of them are hard science fiction and I'm less into those. If you want to borrow any Ellison, Zelazney, Bester, Dick, let us know.

Reply

beowabbit November 13 2006, 02:53:18 UTC
Thanks; actually, I’ve recently joined MITSFS, which is probably marginally more convenient for me to borrow books from than you guys are, but if I’m at your place at a party or something I’ll bear that in mind. I’ve read lots of Ellison and a fair amount of Dick. I haven’t enjoyed what little Zelazney I’ve read, and I don’t think I’ve read any Bester.

Reply

because this is your journal, i can get away with it bitty November 13 2006, 03:02:37 UTC
I’ve read ... a fair amount of Dick.

Reply

Re: because this is your journal, i can get away with it lilbjorn November 13 2006, 03:17:03 UTC
Nobody's here is going to criticize you for being into Dick.

Reply


treacle_well November 13 2006, 03:11:18 UTC
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, Philip K. Dick [This was a book? I thought it was a short story. I think I read the short story in an anthology by a different name, but I’m not 100% sure.]

It's a short novel or novella. I've certainly seen books published with that title--though now that I think of it, because it's so short they might have tacked a short story or two into the same book with it--you know Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep and other stories. Also, I believe most, if not all, of Dick's work has been published in "collected works of..." volumes, so it's very possible you encountered it in such a collection.

Reply


lilbjorn November 13 2006, 03:18:24 UTC
I can't fathom putting The Silmarillion on the list, even though I've read it twice. Better something like:
Lucifer's Hammer, Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle
The Gentle Giants of Ganymede, James P. Hogan
His Dark Materials trilogy, Philip Pullman

It was nice to see Cordwainer Smith on the list.

I always thought Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? was a short story, too, though I've never read it. My belief was based on the movie saying so.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

derien November 13 2006, 13:14:57 UTC
Having a hard time seeing either The Sword of Shannara or any of the Covenant books here. They've already got Lord of the Rings, no point including the cheap knockoffs.

Seriously! Very cheap knockoffs. :P

Reply

beowabbit November 14 2006, 03:37:58 UTC
I really enjoyed Lucifer’s Hammer, and yes, His Dark Materials is better than two thirds of that list. It might be too soon to know how “influential” it is, though.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up