Chuck Versus the Fan - Otherwise Known As, Which Season is the Best?

[beauparadox]

So. The general view is that season 2 is the be-all-to-end-all of Chuck and that season 3 was a steaming pile with a few highlights here and there. Personally, I do think season 2 was the best and season 3 was the weakest. But! I want to see if that holds up when watching the show and not just thinking back on it, as people tend to romanticize the

Comments

[betgirl]

Wonderful recap! This is one of the very few pilots that managed to get me hooked on a show and look forward to what was to come from the start.

[beauparadox]

Thanks very much! :]

Exactly! This pilot was just so good. It's one of my favorite episodes of the show.

[frankdbunny]

Nice detailed picspam.

For the record, I do agree that season 3 was the weakest season, but I don't think it was a steaming pile. Shaw was a horrible mistake, and the concept of a red test is a bit hard to swallow, but there were a lot of fun moments, and the finale was stellar.

[beauparadox]

Thanks very much :]

I agree, completely. I don't think it was half as bad as the very, very vocal minority do.

[beauparadox]

Thanks very much! :D I love that part so much XD I literally doubled over laughing.

[beauparadox]

I love it! XD

Thanks very much! :D I love yours too XD

[nurrantiel]

Loving this. It's great to hear (hear? whatever) your commentary, especially going back to the "first time seeing" bit. I can't wait to see more.

[beauparadox]

Thank you so much! Yay! I know I can be a bit long-winded, lol, so I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it :D

Also, icon ♥

[xenaclone]

Excellent. My viewing included an additional 'SQUEE! Adam!' when Casey turned up. And yes, he has beautiful eyes [sigh] and pretty much everything else :-)

[beauparadox]

So true! I didn't know he was in the show until I started watching it so I had a squee moment when he showed up :] (yay Jayne and Hamilton ♥ )