Leave a comment

Comments 4

mastadge October 15 2011, 01:23:49 UTC
In some situations an alley may be one's greatest ally.

Reply

barbarienne October 16 2011, 01:37:40 UTC
Alas, that was the opposite of the situation in the story.

Reply


green_knight October 15 2011, 12:59:57 UTC
Where do they *find* these 'copyeditors' and how can I get them to hire me instead?

Personally, I'm a great fan of electronic copyediting; I can ensure continuity better, I can erase my mistakes without trace, I can mark particularly tangled sentences for later and I can read a clean copy of the edited text to find the smaller problems I'd left in in the first pass.

And yes, I currently have to pull out sentences and dump them in a new file to separate them from the sea of red, because otherwise I'd lose the plot completely. (Nonfiction, ESL author.)

Reply

barbarienne October 16 2011, 01:37:18 UTC
There are benefits to electronic copyediting, but for most people, alas, "greater accuracy" is not one of them.

I strongly suspect this was the copyeditor who is very good at continuity issues, works cheap, and is very speedy; but who also SUCKS at mechanics (and did so when she worked on paper).

The author seems generally competent, so I hope she'll spot all the errors in first pass.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up