while I generally think Snape probably did a lot of provoking, we don't really know. I believe a quote from Sirius at some point was that Snape "gave as good as he got", or some variation of that. Really pro-Snape anti-Sirius people tend to regard Sirius as an unreliable narrator, though, in this sense.
When Harry won't let Remus run away with him, Ron and Hermione, Remus lashes out physically, which is a hard scene to read and yet very important for his character. (Some fans argue it could have been written better, myself included, but that's another issue.) God, I don't even remember this. I really need to hurry up with my re-readings. There is so much about the later books that has totally slipped from my mind...
So, I fucking love Sirius. He is one of my personal favorites from the series. I find his story so tragic in a really amazing way, and I love his personality and character. I love everything about him, even (and maybe especially) his flaws. Gah... !!
I love this: In other words, Remus, Sirius and Snape are slaves to
( ... )
I'm kind of "pro-the whole generation was screwed up", so. :P I am inclined to believe that Snape did give as good as he got though, especially from what we see in the DH flashbacks - he was hanging around with future Death Eaters, and called his best friend a mudblood.
So, I fucking love Sirius. He is one of my personal favorites from the series. I find his story so tragic in a really amazing way, and I love his personality and character. I love everything about him, even (and maybe especially) his flaws. Gah... !!
I love Sirius for those same reasons. He's such a fun character.
Comments 2
I believe a quote from Sirius at some point was that Snape "gave as good as he got", or some variation of that. Really pro-Snape anti-Sirius people tend to regard Sirius as an unreliable narrator, though, in this sense.
When Harry won't let Remus run away with him, Ron and Hermione, Remus lashes out physically, which is a hard scene to read and yet very important for his character. (Some fans argue it could have been written better, myself included, but that's another issue.)
God, I don't even remember this. I really need to hurry up with my re-readings. There is so much about the later books that has totally slipped from my mind...
So, I fucking love Sirius. He is one of my personal favorites from the series. I find his story so tragic in a really amazing way, and I love his personality and character. I love everything about him, even (and maybe especially) his flaws. Gah... !!
I love this:
In other words, Remus, Sirius and Snape are slaves to ( ... )
Reply
So, I fucking love Sirius. He is one of my personal favorites from the series. I find his story so tragic in a really amazing way, and I love his personality and character. I love everything about him, even (and maybe especially) his flaws. Gah... !!
I love Sirius for those same reasons. He's such a fun character.
Reply
Leave a comment