Comments | aunt_zelda: What aunt_zelda Thinks: 'Planet of the Ood' (Alert: I Now Love Donna)

aunt_zelda

What aunt_zelda Thinks: 'Planet of the Ood' (Alert: I Now Love Donna)

Apr 22, 2008 22:30

Ok, some of you think this episode is crap. I disagree with that sentiment. Some of you think the Doctor and Donna did nothing at all and should have sat this one out because the Ood were doing pretty damn well by themselves. I reluctantly have to agree with that.

Personally I think the writer - Keith Temple - should stick around. This wasn’t a ( Read more... )

planet of the ood, doctor who, the master, what aunt_zelda thinks, dw, donna noble, ood

Comments 7

lovemyfaceoff April 23 2008, 04:26:29 UTC

I actually loved this episode a lot. It wasn't the best but I thought it was pretty damn good. AND NOW I LOVE DONNA. I KNEW I WOULD GET TO LIKE HER.
Omg, the part with the ood song of captivity made my eyes water.

aunt_zelda April 23 2008, 17:26:21 UTC

I agree with everything you just said. But my eyes didn't water until they were free and singing in circles.
YAY DONNA!

lovemyfaceoff April 25 2008, 05:06:57 UTC

I'm so glad I like her now. She's really grown on me.

aunt_zelda April 25 2008, 14:44:39 UTC

She is funny and wonderful and a perfect gateway character. She asks the questions we'd ask. She has a very sensible approach to time-travel.

(Your icon makes me sad! Ianto is not alone! And if Jack's abandoned him, I'll be very happy to replace Jack!)

Thread 6

(The comment has been removed)

aunt_zelda April 23 2008, 17:57:11 UTC

I loved Martha, and Rose was alrightThing is, you've gotta look at the big picture with Companions. Rose did what needed to be done. Nine was this raw, naked, BROKEN being. She took the Doctor's hand and led him away from the Abyss that he was pretty damn close to leaping into. She showed him how to live again, she healed him, she gave him clothes. That's how we get Ten from Nine, because of Rose. If we hadn't had Rose, I believe the Master would have found the Doctor, pretended he was helping him, and actually pushed him into the Abyss. And I really, really, REALLY don't want to think about that ( ... )