Comments | athanarel: Nice review of Treason's Shore

asakiyume in athanarel

Nice review of Treason's Shore

Sep 18, 2009 18:34

I stumbled upon this review in my travels through cyberspace.

The fantastic fourth and final Inda fantasy (see INDA, THE FOX and KING’S SHIELD) is a super ending to an excellent saga as the prime characters constantly must choose between personal desires and kingdom needs. The choices are not easy as loyalty to a king may prove treasonous to a ( Read more... )

inda books

Comments 14

sartorias September 18 2009, 22:41:45 UTC

Thanks, asakiyume!

faerie_writer September 18 2009, 22:47:01 UTC

At some point after I've finished working on my grant application, I totally plan on raving about The Fox! You're amazing, Sherwood! What a story! *does-an-I'm-not-worthy-bow* ;)

sartorias September 18 2009, 22:53:15 UTC

Oh I am so glad you enjoyed it!

faerie_writer September 18 2009, 22:44:56 UTC

I just finished book 2. You're making me lust after book 4 before I've read 3. ;)

estara September 19 2009, 17:43:13 UTC

Yay for positive words, however Harriet Klausner has to be taken with a grain of salt, vis Meljean Brook's experience

http://www.theoddshots.com/2009/09/there-are-bad-reviews-and-then-theres-harriet/
But as she points out, Harriet's reviews usually up the stars on Amazon.

sartorias September 19 2009, 17:45:47 UTC

Yeah...witness getting Signi's reaction utterly wrong. O well, better than a slamdunk and getting things wrong--that's so very frustrating.

estara September 19 2009, 17:52:41 UTC

Oh right, the status wasn't important to her. I overread that.

estara September 19 2009, 17:50:53 UTC

Having checked it out on Amazon it's nice to see that she managed to get all the details right this time, however the people in the comments on her review obviously haven't read the book yet and so do a general warning about Harriet.

I think it's probably better that Diana Paxon wrote such a glowing review ^^.

Thread 10