Challenge 2-5: Results

[garrus]

Thanks to everyone who voted or participated in this challenge! However, we have to say goodbye to 3 people this week. Here are the results.

Comments

[aerialle]

congrats to all the people who made it! <3

[pinkosa]

rofl i am not surprised at all XD
and congrats to shixon <33333~ her icon was so lovely! <33333

[pinkosa]

btw, you forgot to screen the replies XD

[garrus]

Replies to the results post are never screened. XD;

[pinkosa]

oh yez...i totally forgot about it XDDDDD i should go to sleep right now, my brain doesn't work after 12pm HAHAHA XD

[shixon]

... ;O;

i'm still in, super yay! and first time as people's choice thank you so much ♥ :) so nervous on getting voted out ;-;

[shixon]

i forgot.. comments and crits for #1 please?

[scanky_chops]

Still in! Comments (here please cos i don't do the e-mail thing)?

[omfg_its_tiffy]

Er, which number were you?

[scanky_chops]

LOL #4 thanks.

[omfg_its_tiffy]

NEGATIVE
- The text isn't really flattering since it is randomly big. The texture is overused also.
- The text doesn't really match the overall presentation of the icon, and the effects like the outline is barely visible. The picture looks grainy.
- Not much going on here. It appears to be brushes and (too) simple text piled onto an image with next to no effects added onto it.

POSITIVE
+ Love the cropping, and text choice
+ i like how the stroke matches her shirt~ ♥
+ Good crop, good coloring. I'm not so hot on the typography, because it's so ON her, but it's pretty good.

[oulan]

Comments for #2 please? ^^