Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury...

[ash48]

Lost soulless puppy or devil in disguise?

I present the case for Sam Winchester: a devil in disguise.

Comments

[debbiel66]

I tend to think Sam is merely (merely!) soulless. I think that's enough of a twist for them, and Supernatural is pretty good about keeping things manageable for the most part. They've got to know that the brotherly interaction is what we all signed up for, and I'm hopeful that episode 7 is a sign of what's to come.

Other than that, I have no thoughts because I must return to gaze at pictures. Guh.

[ash48]

Hee! Yeah... "merely"... surely that's enough! :)

I'm all for them settling here and keeping it all manageable. I admit I will probably be miffed if some reason isn't given for all of Sam weird behaviour. I mean, I know it could all be down to him not having a soul. We know nothing yet of what it is to be without a soul in this 'verse, so yeah... I will buy that (as I did straight after the episode).

*gazes at pictures with you* <333

[greenpear]

Even without watching the show this entry is a hoot. It shows how much you love you show...

[ash48]

Hee! I just wanted to have a bit of fun. Show is so damn DEEP at the moment. :)

And um... yep... my love shows eh?? :D :D

[greenpear]

Dear, it's shown from the day I first met you. :)

[ash48]

That's it!!!! I don't what "cheap answers". I want this all to have meant something. In many ways I don't really care what they do (well, I do.. but.. you know...) as long as what we've seen up until know means something other than just throwing it in to add mystery.

And SAM IS DAMN HOT!!! No argument there! <333

[monicawoe]

I think Sam isn't human. All of your points above are evidence of that, but also- I can't accept that a human body can go to Hell and house Lucifer and return from that still human. Beyond this there is still Castiel's proclamation from season 4 that Sam would change permanently from drinking enough demon blood to kill Lilith. Not only did Sam drink enough to kill Lilith, he drank more than that in season 5 when under Famine's influence, and even more before saying yes to Lucifer! He has to have been permanently changed.

I think there is more to Sam being different this season than just a missing soul.

[ash48]

Hmm... good point.

I've always suspended my disbelief in regards to the condition of the body after Hell. Dean was looking pretty damn good when he got back. I figured Sam was "healed", in terms of him body, the same way Dean was. So who ever raised him worked the same mojo

Though interesting about him being permanently changed due to drinking demon blood. I hadn't considered that.

I have to hope though that there is a way back for Sam. Especially if he's not human any more.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I'm looking forward to finding it all out.
:)

[ash48]

Thank you. :)

And yes, looking back on those scenes just kills doesn't it?

Knowing their bond has such depth and history helps me have hope for the future. Hope that we will see that care again. (soon would be nice...)

Thanks for dropping by. :)