Leave a comment

Comments 9


meryddian May 10 2009, 07:25:26 UTC
Although she was good enough and did the job, I'm still at a lose to understand why Winona Ryder was cast as Amanda.... Was there a cut scene of her being younger?

I couldn't understand this either. She only looks vaguely like Jane Wyatt, and in the scene where she's talking to Spock before he goes into the tribunal, I kept thinking the white streaks in her hair looked more like bird poop than actual grey hair.

I would've preferred to have them cast an unknown in such a small role.

Reply

arky_tiger May 10 2009, 13:45:47 UTC
Yeah I would have preferred them to cast someone of appropriate age, whether an unknown or not.

I have heard though that there is a cut scene of her as a young woman, so presumably this why they cast her... though it would have made more sense to leave that scene in...

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

arky_tiger September 23 2009, 20:46:10 UTC
Lmao! Thanks :)

Reply


finally saw it anonymous November 8 2009, 00:24:16 UTC
so came back to read what you wrote months ago...and i agree on pretty much everything. except i quite liked the cute alien sidekick ( ... )

Reply


whoops chinhippy November 8 2009, 00:26:54 UTC
not only did i not spell check that, but i also forgot to say who i was.

it was me.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up