I liked Haeley, too -- she's got that "quality" about her that even when she misses the notes, I just want to root for her. :) I actually think she'll be safe because Simon tore her apart so much.
Was surprised by how much I liked Katelyn -- she stood out for me last night. :) Michelle, too -- even if it was a carbon copy of the original, Idols used to be able to do that and get away with it. Not in this Brave New David Cook/Kris Allen World, I guess. ;p
Objectively, I can see how Katie Stevens has a good voice, but she did NOT deserve the last spot, and the entitled...it BUGS. I'll take Crystal "doing this for a paycheck" Bowersox any day. :)
Eh, they weren't as changing-it-up folks as David and Kris, but the past winners didn't do carbon-copies either. Michelle did, and that bugs me a little. Put some of yourself into it, she didn't at all.
I think Haeley did good overall, Katie was definitely a wreck.
Comments 6
Ex: I only caught Katie's performance... but wouldn't a popular pop song have been a better choice at this stage in the game?
Reply
Reply
Was surprised by how much I liked Katelyn -- she stood out for me last night. :) Michelle, too -- even if it was a carbon copy of the original, Idols used to be able to do that and get away with it. Not in this Brave New David Cook/Kris Allen World, I guess. ;p
Objectively, I can see how Katie Stevens has a good voice, but she did NOT deserve the last spot, and the entitled...it BUGS. I'll take Crystal "doing this for a paycheck" Bowersox any day. :)
Reply
I think Haeley did good overall, Katie was definitely a wreck.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment