Challenge 5: Round Three: Voting

[enriana]

First, the unfortunate part.

The following people did not enter and were out of skips, so they have been eliminated:
cinieme
cobrasnaps
ijuslokinocent6

Sorry, guys, hope you stick around for voting and the next challenge.

The following people did not enter; one of their skips was automatically used:
bucue
exosomatic
lozzy_babe06
kurren
mell1e
orlandogirl

As a reminder, you can still earn skips! Just promote the community

Comments

[xenylamine]

Worst Quality:
06 - Bad image quality, poor cropping, poor sense of style, poor execution, terrible color, bad typography. It is uncertain what the icon maker was trying to accomplish here.

15 - Good cropping, but poor use of texture and embellishment. The icon elements look out of place with one another.

20 - Good concept, but poor execution. Also, a bit more contrast in the image would have worked wonders.

Personal Favorite:
09 - Beautiful arrangement, it looks like a scrapbook.

19 - Hooray for Star Wars! The text, though, is a little unreadable, maybe a different font would have worked better.

[sunflower_pixie]

Worst Quality

[sra33]

Oh this is impossible. Everyone's is so pretty.

Worst Quality:
01 - Oversharpened, the icon doesn't seem to flow with itself, it seems cut off.
08 - The cropping seems really awkward
10 - The icon is too busy, it's very hard to tell what it's of.

Personal Favorite:
17 - I love the color theme, and how the text just subtly pops out at you.
16 - The colors are soft and feminine and I absolutely adore the flower brush used.

[aladriana]

Worst Quality:
19 - Very grainy, the text is hard to read. Another font, and possible bigger would have worked more.
02- Pixalated, and very small. the Grey overwhelms the picture, making what's in the box dwarfed.
10: It's likely fairly well done, except the text is unreadable, and the picture inside the box unseeable. Mostly, it's too busy.

Personal Favorite:
17 - The coloring is beautiful and the picture is very clear
o4 - Pretty colors, the picture is clear and the text fits well.

[sidhex3]

Worst Quality:
12 - text looks pixelated
19 - great text, but poor image quality
20 - image looks washed out, plain white background is boring

Personal Favorite:
3
4