Challenge 5: Round Three: Voting

[enriana]

First, the unfortunate part.

The following people did not enter and were out of skips, so they have been eliminated:
cinieme
cobrasnaps
ijuslokinocent6

Sorry, guys, hope you stick around for voting and the next challenge.

The following people did not enter; one of their skips was automatically used:
bucue
exosomatic
lozzy_babe06
kurren
mell1e
orlandogirl

As a reminder, you can still earn skips! Just promote the community

Comments

[bucue]

I apologise for not entering! I had been meaning to say I wouldn't but it slipped my mind!

Worst Quality:
11 - The text doesn't fit the box.
13 - Poor choice of brush and too much open space
15 - bad colours and terrible textures.

Personal Favorite:
01 - I really like the colours,
02 - Cute little picture which uses the space well while not filling it.

[tabettha]

Worst Quality:
6 - Too grainy and seems out of focus
15 - The background texture doesn't go with the rest of the image
16 - Text of some kind would be fitting

Personal Favorite:
14
17

[shadowsong_13]

Worst Quality:
01 - Icon is very oversharpened
10 - Texture and text overpowering, can't tell what's in the icon
17 - The words in the texture are very distracting and pull focus from the image, text gets lost

Personal Favorite:
03
18

[devilishdestiny]

Worst Quality:
10 - it's hard to read the text
20 - the placement of the picture within the larger box grates on me. i would like it better if it was just a little more to the left so hat the bottom and left borders would be even.
08 - it needs something to add a little interest. maybe a brush to make it look more like a photograph?

Personal Favorite:
17 - very well put together
05 - one of the best examples of the photograph look that i've seen

OOPS, I forgot one

[girlboheme]

Worst Quality:
06 - the placement of the square makes him look a bit defomed. Lovely subject matter though.
10 - Determining the subject of the icon is really difficult. The pic in the middle is too washed out.
08 - The tilt of the image is really awkward.

Personal Favorite:
03 - I like it's softness, the word works well with the icon
05 - very pretty colors and unique.