9.2 Voting

[sidhex3]

Skipping: setentpet and cyanidexbeauty

Rules:
- You will be voting for ONE lesser quality icons and for ONE best icon. Vote according to quality and technique, not personal preference. Please be as specific as possible. Vague and/or ambiguous comments will only force me to ask you for clarification. ;) If there is a problem with your vote, I will ask you to change it

Comments

[juniorfan29]

LEAST:
004- The coloring is too dark, the focus seems a little over sharpened in some places, and the font is 'blurry' and fuzzy.

BEST:
001- Clear and crisp picture, good coloring, background compliments the overall icon nicely, font is clean and readable.

[holidaylights]

LEAST:
#03 - The center crop takes the focus off the bear's expression, and the white areas seem a little blown out, especially at the edges of the fur on his head.

BEST:
#07 - Nice coloring, cropping, and use of textures.

[czarnalukrecja]

LEAST:
#06 - the coloring is okay, but the text doesn't fit somehow. and the A in 'approve' shold have a different color, cause the stone in the background is too bright

BEST:
#02 - black and white fits the icon very well

[ender839]

LEAST:
#007 - The light texture doesn't really add anything to the icon, but instead takes the eye away from the focus, namely the bear. It's also a bit difficult to make out the facial features of the bear, which might be a result of under-done contrasting.

BEST:
#003 - The coloring and contrast here are fantastic - the details in the fur pop, despite the overall light coloring. Wonderfully done!

[winterlillies]

Let me know if there are any problems.

LEAST:
#07 - Crop is awkward and if it's suppose to be a black and white icon there is just too blue and the pink light texture does not add any emphasis to the overall composite of the icon.

BEST:
#05 - Overall good crop and good use of color.