[Round 02: Challenge 2] Results

[whiteplums]

Hiii. Firefox froze on me as I was posting this and I almost had a heart attack :I

Comments

[nabreus]

crits for #30 plz

[orlandogirl]

oh wow,thank you so much for mods choice!^^; im so glad you liked it :D and i love a banner if it wouldnt be too much trouble :)

also may i have my comments for #21?^_^

[garrus]

Wait. Wait. Not only did I not get eliminated, but two people actually FAVED my super ugly icon? What is this? @___@; Crits for #29, please.

[victorisham]

Woo, I got my total back to 0! 8D

Any comments for 33? Unscreened, please.

[monochroma]

NEGATIVES
- The picture looks plain and simple, but the green pattern looks out of place and doesn't flow with the browns/reds in the main picture. There seems to be no focus at all, and I don't know what to exactly look at in this picture. The choice of crop isn't an easy one, so it kind of explains the main problem here. Changing the crop might have made this icon better.
- The strip of green on the top doesn't match at all. Perhaps another color would've worked better.

POSITIVES
+ Really good cropping here; it made the icon really distinctive. The coloring's nice and strong as well.
+ (no comment)

[carupico]

...

...What?

Uh, crits for #24, please~ And I'd like a banner, as well. ^^

This is just too weird.