Leave a comment

Comments 22

gonzo21 September 23 2015, 11:45:04 UTC
I have never heard any of those words for snow before.

I'm astonished so few people care about the Prime Minister being blackmailed by a senior donator to the party. Absolutely astonished.

Reply

ggreig September 23 2015, 12:01:36 UTC
I might use "snaw" - how marked my Scots speech is depends on who I'm talking to - and I would know what was meant if someone said "snaw-pouther" or "spitters". I only know "skelf" as a word for "splinter", and wouldn't easily adjust to it meaning "a large snowflake", though context might help.

It's a "Historical Thesaurus of Scots" that's being compiled though; so it'll include a lot of words that may not be in current usage.

Reply

gonzo21 September 23 2015, 12:06:48 UTC
'Snaw' to me is just 'snow' pronounced with a certain scottish accent though. I don't think it qualifies as a whole new word on its own.

And yeah, skelf to me is a splinter.

Reply

ggreig September 23 2015, 12:31:06 UTC
That way lies a huge argument over the difference between Scots (the language) and Scottish English (dialects of English) - which argument, I hasten to say, I'm not looking to have and would be unqualified to do so anyway.

However, if you accept that Scots exists as a language and that the context is a Scots thesaurus then I think it's OK to say that "snaw" is a Scots word. We wouldn't disqualify "brave" from being a French word on the grounds that it's just the English "brave" pronounced with a French accent. :-)

Reply


chess September 23 2015, 14:27:17 UTC
Numbers of Tory respondents in the piggate survey were very low - and I would expect 'population of Conservatives who do YouGov surveys' to correspond pretty well with 'more Libertarian-side Tories who couldn't care less what you do with your penis and inanimate objects' whereas your more social-conservative Tories are less likely to be filling in surveys on the internet...

Reply

alextfish September 24 2015, 22:38:29 UTC
YouGov are generally fairly good at weighting their survey responses to take account of that kind of thing. But that article does seem to talk about raw numbers of respondents. YouGov do also try to distribute the people they invite to answer certain questions across a range of demographics etc, so... I don't know.

Reply


momentsmusicaux September 23 2015, 14:38:52 UTC
I really want to believe that graph, but surely that's a sample of people across different ages, rather than trajectories. So while that doesn't discount it, we have to consider the world that different generations have grown up in. Current 60somethings have been living in a world that's got better and better for them, for instance.

Reply


apostle_of_eris September 25 2015, 21:19:01 UTC
Why is the pig thing about one guy and not about Oxbridge? It's not like he invented the thing.
(sidebar on what a foul creature Thatcher was)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up