Leave a comment

Comments 16

bart_calendar April 27 2012, 11:17:41 UTC
I always thought the standard for Priests reporting things in confession was the same as that for psychologists and psychiatrists ( ... )

Reply

cartesiandaemon April 27 2012, 11:39:49 UTC
That would make sense.

I imagine the grey area would be someone confessing that they'd repeatedly done something illegal, such that the confessor will guess they probably will do it again whether they intend to or not.

Although I'm not sure if the furoror is over what the rules actually are, or rather over a suggestion (very true, but probably somewhat inflated by anti-catholic feeling) that many priests will overlook evidence about molestation which they wouldn't overlook about eg murder.

Reply

bart_calendar April 27 2012, 11:42:22 UTC
If you confess to a murder or other violent crimes a priest won't report it. (Otherwise much of Northern Ireland would have had to give up their faith.)

It's only if you say you are going to murder someone that they will report it - and they still have to get you to say it outside the confessional booth (which wouldn't be that hard with someone very Catholic. You just have say "we need to talk about his in the rectory.)

Reply


cartesiandaemon April 27 2012, 11:32:48 UTC
"Catholic schools launch 'eurgh, benders' petition"

I honestly assumed that was a link to one of the real news articles about the petition, just with a sarcastic headline on the link...

Reply

andrewducker April 27 2012, 11:36:18 UTC
It really is one of those stories where satire is near-impossible, because real life is already so fucked up.

Reply


bracknellexile April 27 2012, 11:37:39 UTC
Message in human DNA: "Humanity ver.2.2 (C) God, 3000 BC. You clone, I'll sue!"

Reply


cartesiandaemon April 27 2012, 11:41:34 UTC
"Game of Thrones as a metaphor for US politics (funny)"

That's awesome, I love the punchline with the last pairing.

Stupid question, which is the politician paired with Tyrion?

Reply

innerbrat April 27 2012, 11:50:09 UTC
Is Tyrion the one linked with Stephen Colbert?

Reply

cartesiandaemon April 27 2012, 11:53:00 UTC
Ah! Yes, thank you.

Reply

innerbrat April 27 2012, 11:54:34 UTC
The trouble with one knowing more about US politic(al comedy) than Game of Thrones! I could have explained who Colbert was and about his SuperPAC, but I guess you don't need it now?

Reply


philmophlegm April 27 2012, 13:13:56 UTC
Barack Obama = Robb Stark? No.

Someone who starts a major war motivated by revenge without any thought to what would happen if he actually won is clearly George W Bush.

The rest are pretty good though.

Reply

spacelem April 27 2012, 14:31:00 UTC
I'm amused by Renly being matched up to Santorum (I wonder if Santorum would be equally amused?)

I love the bit about Ed Stark/Al Gore going on about climate change, and Robert Baratheon/Bill Clinton is perfect!

Reply

philmophlegm April 27 2012, 14:48:43 UTC
Someone needs to do this for British politics.

I thought of a couple:
Ed Milliband = Renly Baratheon: Betrayed his brother. Followers are naive and idealistic.

Alex Salmond = Mance Rayder: Wants to be King Beyond the Wall.

Gordon Brown = Stannis Baratheon: Should have been next in line, but nobody likes him.

Reply

marrog April 27 2012, 15:12:00 UTC
British politics is, thankfully, not quite enough of a farce yet to be broken down and compared to a series of fictional characters.

I hope.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up