Comments | amy_contest: Challenge ONE-HUNDO-BABY

notashamed in amy_contest

Challenge ONE-HUNDO-BABY

Jul 11, 2008 15:19

We've made it to 100 challenges! Whee! To celebrate, we'll be doing things a little different this week (idea blatantly stolen from ev_indulgence but emeraldsolitude suggested it so NYEAH)You must take an older icon that you just totally dislike and "make it better." Obviously you must use the same picture, but beyond that just create a better over-all icon. So you can take, ( Read more... )

challenge: special, 100

Comments 23

amyleesesshy July 21 2008, 03:26:31 UTC

do we need to put url? i put it in case you want it.

notashamed July 21 2008, 03:32:01 UTC

nah, I don't need the url, but thanks :)

amyleesesshy July 21 2008, 03:46:53 UTC

Alright! should I redo my comment or just leave it?

notashamed July 21 2008, 14:36:35 UTC

oh don't worry about it. i can ignore them. thanks!

jadedanielle July 21 2008, 04:46:52 UTC

( ... )

notashamed July 31 2008, 00:55:51 UTC

Set E: new: the new icon is much softer and has beautiful coloring.
Set E: NEW - while i do love the colors in the old one, the smoothness of the new one is much better
Set E: new (I like the softer colouring)
Set E: New- The icon isn't too oversharpened and the composition isn't too busy.
Set E: NEW(I like the softness of this icon. The coloring is also great. )
Set E: new I like the color because its simple and a bit light.

sick_forever July 21 2008, 11:09:15 UTC

old=

( ... )

New icons preferred notashamed July 31 2008, 00:59:31 UTC

Set F: new Its sharper and the tag line is simple. Overall look it capture me more than the old one.
Set F:NEW (It's messed up how it looks like her right arm is cut but I like it. )
Set F: New - The old icon is about as good, but the text in the new icon is better placed and the dark coloring is more flattering
Set F: New- The font coincides with the icon and I like how the icon isn't focused entirely on Amy.
Set F: NEW - better crop, better font
Set F: new: The crop on this icon is much better, and the lesser amount of text keeps it simple but to the point.

Set K:new I like light effect
Set K:NEW (I like both of these icons but I prefer the textures of the new icon)
Set K: New - The coloring nn the new icon is gorgeous!
Set K: New- I like the coloring and the textures used to bring out the colors.
Set K: NEW - better crop
Set K: new: the second icon has a smooth feel to it, and the colors suit the icon better.

harrypotterchic July 21 2008, 13:47:57 UTC

1. OLD =

( ... )

New icons preferred (close vote!) notashamed July 31 2008, 01:03:14 UTC

Set G: old I like the phrase your way ( ... )

(The comment has been removed)

notashamed November 7 2012, 20:23:38 UTC

omg you do??? that's so adorable. I totally am attracted to you too. let's meet.