FAVOURITES: 03 - I like the dynamic feel of the icon, the text placement is perfect and the grid/line texture is a perfect choice. 03 - Very nice composition and fantastic text. 03 - I absolutely adore the composition of this icon and the fact that you worked with such a small image. The vectoring and recoloring is great and the textures and shadow give the icon a lot of depth. My only critique is that Mugen's crotch is a liiitle over-sharpened in comparison to everything else. 03 - I really like the texture and the background color,and how you changed the arrows to white so that it blends in better. 03 - The coloring is really lovely, especially compared to the original image. The dramatic pose with the arrows and the text all work together so well together, so the icon is very eye-catching. 03 - I like the composition of the icon and how the arrow colour has been changed.
LEAST FAVOURITES: -
ADDITIONAL03 - love the crop and the dynamics of the icon, and the text in the background is really well done
( ... )
FAVOURITES: 12 - Amazing coloring, not just from the manga image but the icon itself. I like the stark lights and deep shadows. 12 - I have no idea how you could do such a fabulous coloring from that scan.The shadows and lightning are just so so beautiful I cannot stop flailing over it.
LEAST FAVOURITES: 12 - To be honest I couldn't tell what was going on in the icon until I saw the original image. The manga coloring is great but the lightning/contrast is quite overwhelming.
ADDITIONAL 12 - I really like the colors and the compistion of this icon, a really nice job. 12 - I really love the colouring in this icon, it's amazing how I can see the lights and shadows here. The random blobs of colour in the background kinda distracts me though. 12 - I like the manipulation of the original image but overall the colours seem very dark and my eye is drawn to the background more than the character.
FAVOURITES: 05 - Very lovely coloring! #5 - The icon's composition, while not extravagant, is no less beautiful. Less can be better. 05 - Great use of text and i enjoy de vibrant colors. 05 - I really like the trio of colors that you used, and you did such a great job extracting stringy oldschool shoujo hair! The yellow shadow under "calling" is a really nice touch, too. 05 - wow the colouring is really awesome, it looks so different from the original scan, it's more vibrant and lively now!
Comments 12
Could I please have my crits? :) (screened)
Reply
Thank you guys! :D
My crits would be lovely to see (unscreened is fine).
Reply
03 - I like the dynamic feel of the icon, the text placement is perfect and the grid/line texture is a perfect choice.
03 - Very nice composition and fantastic text.
03 - I absolutely adore the composition of this icon and the fact that you worked with such a small image. The vectoring and recoloring is great and the textures and shadow give the icon a lot of depth. My only critique is that Mugen's crotch is a liiitle over-sharpened in comparison to everything else.
03 - I really like the texture and the background color,and how you changed the arrows to white so that it blends in better.
03 - The coloring is really lovely, especially compared to the original image. The dramatic pose with the arrows and the text all work together so well together, so the icon is very eye-catching.
03 - I like the composition of the icon and how the arrow colour has been changed.
LEAST FAVOURITES:
-
ADDITIONAL03 - love the crop and the dynamics of the icon, and the text in the background is really well done ( ... )
Reply
Reply
12 - Amazing coloring, not just from the manga image but the icon itself. I like the stark lights and deep shadows.
12 - I have no idea how you could do such a fabulous coloring from that scan.The shadows and lightning are just so so beautiful I cannot stop flailing over it.
LEAST FAVOURITES:
12 - To be honest I couldn't tell what was going on in the icon until I saw the original image. The manga coloring is great but the lightning/contrast is quite overwhelming.
ADDITIONAL
12 - I really like the colors and the compistion of this icon, a really nice job.
12 - I really love the colouring in this icon, it's amazing how I can see the lights and shadows here. The random blobs of colour in the background kinda distracts me though.
12 - I like the manipulation of the original image but overall the colours seem very dark and my eye is drawn to the background more than the character.
Reply
Reply
05 - Very lovely coloring!
#5 - The icon's composition, while not extravagant, is no less beautiful. Less can be better.
05 - Great use of text and i enjoy de vibrant colors.
05 - I really like the trio of colors that you used, and you did such a great job extracting stringy oldschool shoujo hair! The yellow shadow under "calling" is a really nice touch, too.
05 - wow the colouring is really awesome, it looks so different from the original scan, it's more vibrant and lively now!
LEAST FAVOURITES:
-
ADDITIONAL:
-
Reply
Leave a comment