Leave a comment

Comments 37

astrokittie May 12 2013, 08:41:56 UTC
pssst I think you linked to the old spreadsheet because it still says I'm in 1st place.

Reply

kayable May 12 2013, 09:23:06 UTC
just click the round 2 tab at the bottom? idk if they have separate links for different tabs

also crits unscreened?

Reply

absolutelybatty May 12 2013, 09:30:46 UTC
They do! If you switch out the number after #gid= (right now it says 0) to one it should link to the second tab in the spreadsheet! Like this!

Reply

kayable May 12 2013, 09:38:02 UTC
!! Thank you!!

Reply


cool_spectrum May 12 2013, 08:42:05 UTC
I'd like my crits, screened please~

Reply


absolutelybatty May 12 2013, 08:52:19 UTC
I WAS NOT EXPECTING THIS. I AM GOING TO GO CRY IN A CORNER. OH MY GOD. THANK YOU. ♥
Also, hah, I was looking at the points and thinking 'holy crap on a cracker, 45 people voted?!!!' before I remembered that icons were ranked. I am intelligent.

Um, comments would be lovely! Unscreened is totally fine. =D

Reply

kayable May 12 2013, 09:41:24 UTC
MAIN:
08 - I'm not a fan of the supplied text but you used it flawlessly!
08 - I love the coloring in this icon so much, it's bright and smooth without feeling overpowering. The texture to the right and the text fading into background are also a fantastic touch. It's such a really great icon, great job!
08 - Composition is perfect. I love the faded text in the background. And the coloring is also flawless <33

BONUS:
02 - I love the soft luminous quality to the editing.
02 - This icon is a bit too dark, almost burnt looking, but the composition is FANTASTIC.
02 - The coloring is absolutely beautiful, there's something about it that I really like. I also like how you used both images in the composition too, really creative.
02 - I love the brightness of the colors! The reds are so bold and vibrant which is a great contrast with the bright blues~

Reply


aeriiths May 12 2013, 08:53:25 UTC
Oh wow, thanks so much for first! Congrats to everyone else too, there were some really lovely icons this challenge.

I'd like my crits please, unscreened is fine.

Reply

absolutelybatty May 12 2013, 08:54:53 UTC
Your icon was stealthy! I thought after turbo_rumble I'd be able to spot your stuff a mile away, but NOPE. Congratulations though! It's a super cute icon! =D

Reply

aeriiths May 12 2013, 09:02:27 UTC
ngl I usually use wayyyy more textures on my icons than I did on this one, so maybe that was why! Thank you so much though, I've been in this big ol' iconning rut lately so I'm pretty surprised that it turned out the way it did.

Also can I just say that your Spirited Away icon is perfect I mean wow, those colours ♥

Reply

absolutelybatty May 12 2013, 09:13:46 UTC
Mmm! That might be why for sure! That and the absence of your amazing text work, I think! Hopefully this helped you out of that rut, hey? ♥

Thank you! Most of it is just the movie itself, I think. Hee! :D

Reply


margerydaw_s2 May 12 2013, 11:41:39 UTC
Congrats, everyone!

I'd like my crits/comments, unscreened is fine :)

Reply

kayable May 12 2013, 13:45:04 UTC
MAIN
05 - Truly stunning coloring! If I hadn't clicked on the original image, I would have thought you colored it from scratch!
5 - I love the mistiness and lighting in this close crop :)
05 - This icon has a great start and looks incredible for coming from such a blurry screencap, but I feel it could use to be a little sharper and have more contrast, especially around the eyes.
05 - I really wish I had an extra spot to vote for this icon, it's so pretty! The close crop works so well and the coloring's amazing.
05 - The richness of the colors, and the additional shading you added is just perfect!
05 - Love that you painted over the cap, the lightning is gorgeous!

BONUS01 - Pretty blending and the warm coloring really suits the tone of the image ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up