Freud

Jul 25, 2005 22:07

I have a quick question about Freud's Oedipus theory - obviously everyone knows the basics of it, and it comes up in a bunch of his writings, but where does it come up initially? Or rather, in which work would I find it laid out and defined? Basically I need it for a citation (one of these things you mention in your thesis and then have to ( Read more... )

freud

Leave a comment

Comments 36

solelo July 25 2005, 21:05:42 UTC
Interpretation_of_Dreams, 1899 or 1900 (depending).

Reply

solelo July 25 2005, 21:12:31 UTC
(In the Penguin Freud Library edition of I. of D., Freud introduces the theory on page 364.)

Also, I did more looking. Use 1900 for the pub. date. :)

Reply

girl_in_blue July 25 2005, 21:55:50 UTC
thanks so much!

Reply

solelo July 25 2005, 22:26:21 UTC
No problem.

Reply


theoria July 25 2005, 23:06:05 UTC
So, what you're saying, then, is that you want to cite something you haven't bothered to read. Indeed, you want to cite something and you don't even know what it is in the first place. Great stuff.

Reply

phasma_aphanes July 25 2005, 23:10:20 UTC
well, one would hope she would actually go and look up the book. of course, she might also look through freud's other works and find the little hans case study as well as a later essay he wrote called "the oedipus complex" where he spells out his more developed theory. but perhaps library research for a thesis is a bit much to ask, don't you think?

Reply

theoria July 25 2005, 23:19:02 UTC
It does seem that way. I can imagine how the sentence runs, "Well, as everyone knows, this Austrian-Jew-Guy discovered some Greek plays and one of them was about some guy who killed his father and fucked his mother. That's about all I know (Freud 1900: 384)".

Reply

phasma_aphanes July 26 2005, 00:03:59 UTC
uumm. that's page 364.

Reply


Aren't you the Gwyneth Paltrow character . . . calaf July 26 2005, 00:54:55 UTC
. . . in The Royal Tanenbaums?

Reply


e4q July 26 2005, 10:56:27 UTC
remember when people read books?

Reply


pansette July 26 2005, 15:07:41 UTC
I've read assloads of Freud, but I couldn't have answered this question off the top of my head...

Of course, that said, I also would've known where to look to find it.

Like, say, http://www.google.com

Reply


Leave a comment

Up