Maybe we should just enjoy this...

Apr 09, 2012 21:33

This week we thought we'd have another fanon vs canon discussion; one centred on New Caprica ( Read more... )

canon vs fanon, discussion post

Leave a comment

Comments 9

newnumbertwo April 9 2012, 12:44:51 UTC
New Caprica hurts my head. Thinking about it and trying to reconcile it with the rest of canon is really difficult for me ( ... )

Reply

bsg_aussiegirl April 12 2012, 06:38:44 UTC
I think Baltar's hopeless administration had a lot to do with their lack of permanent structures as well, if we take the way Laura and Bill talk about him after the exodus. (And the Union unrest.) I suppose we can also say their water/sewrage facilities etc were below par considering their apparent health issues.

They were out on sandbags, so they could look at the stars. *happy shippy sigh*

I like your not Earth theory. :)

And I pretty much agree with everything else you said!

Baltar was a villian, yes. But I never see him being able to railroad Bill and Laura. I think they were madder at him about his apathy for what was going on than his tyranny.

Reply


hollywobbles April 9 2012, 14:48:00 UTC
I am a huge canon whore about New Caprica (and I was seriously beaten up about it back when I was too new to know to keep my mouth shut). I enjoy reading NC secksytime fics as much as the next fangirl, but I generally count them as AU -- I don't really think they did anything, honestly (and honestly, I think that makes their overarching arc more romantic, if sadder). The details like communal showers I don't think much about either way, and I'd buy her having her own tent, although I could see her sharing with Maya as well.

Reply

bsg_aussiegirl April 12 2012, 06:20:36 UTC
I never keep my mouth shut... *snort*

I agree that NC is one big A/U. Especially made for writers who never want to mark their fics as a/u. (See, big mouth, just saying it again...)

Reply


marzipanilla April 9 2012, 21:47:00 UTC
I'm not fond of the 'Baltar sent Laura down to teach' vein in writing much. I'm really sure it was somethnig she chose on her own, without any input from the president. She's probably one of the main reasons the school (and others we didn't see?) existed. Teaching just made her so happy, I see her going back to it long before someone tried to use it to get her to move anywhere ( ... )

Reply

bsg_aussiegirl April 12 2012, 06:28:11 UTC
Oh Gods, should I admit that one of the things I hate the most is fics that have Baltar walking all over Laura and Bill and forcing her to teach, or Bill to never visit NC etc? As soon as I see it in a fic, I think I pretty much stop reading. DRIVES ME NUTS.

She got her own tent when people started dropping like flies!?! You morbid thing, you! LOL

I'll get on board the frakking like bunnies theory. :)

Reply


northeto April 10 2012, 02:14:13 UTC
I would buy the communal showers idea. If they're still living in tents after all that time, they probably don't have the resources (in materials, manpower or time) for building private showers ( ... )

Reply

bsg_aussiegirl April 12 2012, 06:14:55 UTC
I agree they probably had communal showers, but I don't think they were necessarily unisex. :)

Yes, if she did have a roommate, I assume it was Tory. Which does make Tory's ultimate betrayal later in the series harder to take.

I always get the sense from their subsequent conversations that Bill had seen neither the lake or the baby. Just the way they phrased things.

Please don't make me ick out at the thought of Roslin/anyone else paired up on NC... *feeling faint*

Reply

northeto April 13 2012, 03:01:26 UTC
I have to say I have never entirely understood Tory. One day I will rewatch the later seasons now that I know where they were went ultimately with her, and see if her character makes more sense to me.

*feeling faint*
Eeep, sorry! I'm sure I meant to say something about Bill and Laura hanging out on their sandbags giggling and making picnic plans or something... :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up