I'm not sure why, but there was a very brief period around 2000 when it seemed like DC was all about Batman graphic novels by Bob Hall, the former Avengers/Squadron Supreme artist
whose creative decisions--according to Jim Shooter--were inadvertantly responsible for turning Hank Pym into a wife-beater. Oh, and Hall also illustrated the Marvel graphic novel Emperor Doom, where Doom takes over the world, a magnificently badass story that deserved to be reprinted. But Hall just drew those stories, whereas at DC, he became the writer/artist of a handful of Batman prestige format stories.
For whatever reason during 98-00, DC was all about Hall, and Hall was all about the Joker. First, there was the
I, Joker, a particularly weird Elseworlds. Then there was
It's Joker Time, an instantly-dated satire of Jerry Springer style TV. Man, between that,
2003's Jerry Springer: The Opera, and
Peter Gabriel's 2002 single "The Barry Williams Show," what the hell is up with everybody deciding to skewer Springer several years AFTER that show's relevancy period? If It's Joker Time came out a couple years later, it would have been about reality TV, and really, there's way more potential for fun if you had Survivor with the Joker.
Between both of these, there was Batman: D.O.A. Much like
the classic film noir D.O.A., Batman has been poisoned and has to find out who did it and why before time runs out. Unfortunately for the Batman, the story... hell, the actual cover itself... kind of spoils the would-be-killers right away:
Despite being right there, their appearances in the story itself don't amount to more than a pair of extended cameos, but it's certainly notable enough to look at right here! Because frankly, we just don't see enough of the rogues hanging out, y'know?
Oh, just a warning, though: be prepared to ignore the stupidity of the Penguin being in Arkham Asylum. I hate it when writers put him there, ignoring the fact that he's perfectly sane in favor of "Bat-Villains go in here!" But it's okay, because Hall at least uses Ozzie to great purpose, as he and the Gruesome Twosome undergo a different kind of group therapy at Arkham.
I keep thinking that's a downed TARDIS on the bottom there.
I like how Hall writes them as "The Unholy Three," as if they've always been a team. Honestly, I love seeing the Rogues interact, especially if it's the Joker with Harvey and the Joker with Ozzie. The latter one used to be so prevalent in the Silver Age that it's kind of a shame we don't see it anymore. The closest we've come to that recently is, what, Azzarello's Joker, where Ozzie's is frequently and inexplicably referred to as "Abner?" Oy. I like seeing the Joker and Penguin being buddy-buddy, with the Joker showing Ozzie the closest thing to genuine affection that he's capable of having. I'd imagine that the Joker gives Penguin slightly fewer wedgies that he gives Two-Face.
Over the course of Batman: D.O.A., the dying Batman continues to save the innocent (which results in
an ongoing series of odd and nutty hallucinations, such as the Wayne's beckoning Bruce to walk into an explosion and join them) while two of his best friends confront their suspects at Arkham:
"Best two out of three"? Way to not only fundamentally misunderstand Two-Face in the same way that Batman Forever did, but it also kneecaps the point of what Harvey does in the next part:
Ladies and gentleman, I give you a rare example of Two-Face actually being an unpredictable character! What's more, I like that Tim is himself taking a chance and playing Harvey's game, not rigging it to ensure it comes up heads (assuming that he didn't palm the coin and replace it with a fixed one, as I don't think he did). Everyone is equally at risk, and there's Harvey, impartial in the middle of it all. That's an aspect I'd like to see used more often, that Two-Face is both good and evil, and yet simultaneously neither. Wait, does that even make sense? Ow, my brain.
Hmm... maybe that's why these three don't team up more often. Really, even if Harvey hadn't done that, you just know the Joker would have purposely screwed it up himself. The three of them pooling their resources to kill Batman from a distance? Feh! No one gets to share that glory! But then, everything about the way the rogues are written here feels very Silver Age and reminiscent of the Adam West show in a darker modern context, which I think accounts for the Joker acting out of character as we know him today.
You know what? I don't care. I want more leisure and scheming time with Harvey, Ozzie, and Mr. J! There's untapped potential here like... well, like crazy! Well, except in Ozzie's case, but that group needs the sane would to ground the others. Wait, would that make them a perfect team of Lawful Evil, Neutral Evil, and Chaotic Evil? What the hell would Harvey's D&D alignment be, anyway?