When we had straight up salt and burns and people dying in strange and unusual ways.
Or when shit like this comes up and Sam and I would just take the fuck off after it:
Mythical chupacabra 'beast' resurfacesHey Reggie, you better get your people on that. If this is lined up after our search and rescue, Sam and I want in.
I'm going to go finish my coffee and get to work hunting down Cas. Gotta collect some of those things for Willow's ritual.
Oh, and I don't care what Sam thinks. These wiki things are not all that bad.
Here is a list of a bunch of cryptids.