Gift For: Maiden Jedi (Part 2/2)
Title: Closing the Case
Author: bugs
Rating: T
Genre: Casefile, MSR
Word Count: 11,000
Summary: Mulder's tucked away in the country and Scully is dedicated to her new career, but one last case calls for resolution.
~*~
March 3, 1991:
"Agent Mulder, a pathologist down at Quantico has just busted your profile," William Patterson said smugly, tossing a report on Mulder's desk.
He snatched it up. "What the hell are you talking about?"
Patterson leaned on the desk's corner. "I went there myself to challenge her. She stood her ground. You know the type, one of those little girls who started applying to the FBI after Silence of the Lambs hit the bookstores."
Mulder shot his superior an unfriendly look. Sometimes Patterson acted like a man of his generation.
Four bodies had been found on or near the De Paul University campus in an eight month period, murdered by strangulation. Three women and one male, all students at the school, but with no discernible connection to each other. All laid out in a stiff, almost formal pose, flat on their backs and with special care to arranging the limbs. No sexual assault; the victims were still fully clothed.
Mulder had determined the killer was likely another student, possibly in one of the sciences with a rigid and linear outlook. The killing was secondary to the enjoyment he received from the control of possessing, moving and arranging the body. He probably had sexual dysfunction with late puberty triggering the urge to kill, but may also be an older student to have reached this level of proficiency and care.
Mulder and his small task force of two other agents had spent hours a day, seven days a week, pouring over student records. They had even found a primary suspect; Harold Schreiber, a PhD. candidate in physics, unmarried and with no personal relationships, and two juvenile arrests for arson. Mulder had interviewed him and although this did not follow the analytical protocol, found him creepy.
When the fourth body had appeared three weeks ago, it had given Mulder pause. It was a male victim. Although no sexual assault was present, he still felt the killer was displacing feelings toward women in these crimes. The female victims had all had their long hair placed carefully, almost like a wimple, and their clothes were arranged to assure that the limbs were completely covered and modest. Their eyelids were open, the eyes cast upward. The heads were tilted in such a way as to make it appear that the victims were looking heavenward. When Mulder laid the crime scene photographs out, side by side, the image that popped to mind was the Virgin Mary.
Although the latest victim had been male, he had a slight frame and shoulder length hair. It could have been mistaken identification by the killer and then faced with a dead male body, had continued with his ritual. Mulder was sticking with his profile.
But now some teaching pathologist...Mulder opened the folder with a snap...Doctor Dana Scully...had decided that the killer was a laborer of some sort.
Although all the bodies had undergone forensic examinations initially, Doctor Scully had been assigned the latest victim, Joseph Hartley, to review in one of her classes. Once she found a certain substance, she'd pulled the other victims' skin samples, looking for the same thing and had found it--powdered masonry grout; not something a physics scholar would have on his hands.
"Son of a bitch--" Mulder slapped the folder closed.
"Are you still going to pull Schreiber in?" Patterson asked, the small smile playing on his thin lips. Mulder had been his prized student but he enjoyed putting the younger man in his place when the rare opportunity arose.
"I want to talk to this Doctor Scully," Mulder grumbled. "Has she confirmed that this substance is in quantities to suggest a laborer? Maybe there's just some dust in the space where Schreiber stores the bodies before placing them to be found."
"Fox, I wanted to go over that point with you. Have you identified where Schreiber could be keeping the bodies?"
"That's why we need the search warrant," Mulder said, impatient.
"So the answer is no."
Mulder folded his arms and met his mentor's concerned gaze. "You don't feel as though I have enough to bring this guy in?"
"He lives in university housing; spends his breaks at his parents' house, but it's clear out in Pennsylvania. There's just no place to put a body."
"An empty laboratory--"
"Agents have done sweeps of all the science buildings with cadaver dogs off of your profile, Fox. No sign that human remains have been present."
"So you think that I should start looking for laborers?"
Patterson tipped his head forward.
"Fine. But I still want to check in with this Doctor Scully."
Over the next few days, Mulder played phone tag with Dana Scully, never getting more than her cool words on answering machines.
He learned that the university chapel was being remodeled on the campus. Construction had been ongoing for two years, but the finish workers had been applying stonework to the exterior for the past year. The mortar used in the work matched Doctor Scully's findings. He left one more message, grudgingly giving her that credit, but never heard anything back.
The construction had been completed the day Hartley's body had been found and the crew had dispersed. For this sort of skilled labor, few local men had been used.
Mulder and his team began to doggedly track down the men. Three were found immediately and cleared of suspicion. Three more were not. One appeared to have been an illegal Mexican immigrant using a false identity and could not be tracked.
In the next months, with no new deaths, Mulder was put on other cases which took up his time. His girlfriend Diana Fowley left him. And then he was finally assigned to the X-files section, and the Crucible Killer slipped from his consciousness.
X
January 13, 1999:
Mulder poked his head around Scully's hospital door. "You awake?"
Her eyelashes fluttered open. "If I wasn't, I am now."
Disregarding her tone, he entered and pulled a chair to her bedside.
"Bored yet?" he asked with the understanding of someone who'd been in exactly her spot too many times.
"Out of my gourd." She looked up at the muted television with discontentment. "I wish I could get into soaps."
"Who's Erica married this time?" he asked with a grin.
She ignored that. "Shouldn't you be back in DC by now? It's Wednesday.”
"Taking some vacation days," he said, rooting some sunflower seeds out of his pocket. "Not like I've got anything important going on back at headquarters." He popped a seed in his mouth.
"Personnel will be thrilled with you," she noted. "Finally using that mandatory leave."
He snagged her slack hand nearest him and twined his fingers loosely with hers. "See, you're good for something."
Blinking, she was finally able to focus clearly. "Mulder, what's that file you have with you? It's not a vacation if you've brought work with you."
"Why would I have a casefile? Not on any cases." Nonetheless, he tugged the thick folder from under his thigh.
Her rapid mind clicked. "Did you steal someone's case, Mulder?"
"Technically, it's my case. Or it was. And yours." The corner of his mouth lifted with the irony.
She settled back in the pillows. This was going to be better than a soap opera.
"In March, 1991, you shattered the profile done by a brilliant young investigator for a serial killer labeled the Crucible Killer--"
She cocked her eyebrow; no amount of opiate medication could keep it down.
"With dirt--"
"Mortar grout powder," she corrected.
"Whatever."
"Are there more victims?"
He was obviously going to take his time. He started with: "After you blew away my main suspect, I followed your lead and checked the construction workers on a campus renovation project. But the trail went cold and I--" He leaned over her hand and spoke his words like a kiss across her skin. "I...Went in another direction with my career."
"1991," she said slowly.
He straightened in the chair. "It was in part your fault."
"Me?" Her eyebrow shot back up.
"I was pissed off when I got your report. And right then I saw that profiling had become a game. It wasn't about the victims anymore but being the smartest guy in the room. I was going to come down to Quantico and kick your ass--"
"Too bad you didn't. When I saw your name on the initial report, I'd wanted to get a look at the FBI Golden Boy," she said drowsily, "heard you were hot."
He snorted. "Did you just take a hit off your pain meds pump and I didn't notice?"
She lolled her head on the pile of pillows and looked his lean body over. "I think it's remotely plausible that someone would find you hot, Agent Mulder."
Embarrassed, he slumped down in the chair. Sipping out of his shoes, he put his feet up on the bed.
She wasn't finished teasing him. "I was always surprised that you didn't mention this case when we first met. I assumed that you'd forgotten it."
"Do I forget anything?" he challenged her. "When you didn't bring it up, I thought you didn't want to talk about it, like some one night stand gone wrong."
She started to laugh, but then grimaced in pain. He stared at the ceiling rather than watch. With a groan, she rolled on her side and squeezed one of his feet.
"More bodies?" she prompted.
"Two; the most recent one last week. I wouldn't have even known, but I had some time to read the back pages of the Metro section in the Times while hanging out in the waiting room."
She made a throaty huff and rubbed her thumb along the ball of his foot. He hunched his shoulders in delight.
"Remind me of the particulars on his modus operandi," she asked.
He flipped open the file. "Victims are of both sexes, ranging in age from eighteen to thirty-one. The original four victims were all college students at De Paul University, suggesting the killer either attended or worked at the institution. The deaths stopped after the completion of a chapel restoration at the school, also suggesting a connection. That was in 1991."
He turned over a separator in the thick file. "Two new deaths, showing the same posing of the victims. Both located in Hoboken, New Jersey, just across the Hudson from New York," he said, nodding toward the window. "Hannah Morton, a twenty-seven year old clerk at an art supply store. The second victim, found last Saturday, was Rick Bedford, nineteen year old student who lived in his mother's basement. Had the same long straight hair as the sole male victim in the De Paul killings, as well as a slight frame that may be mistaken for a female if the perpetrator makes impulsive selections rather than stalking a possible victim."
Scully broke in, "But the crimes suggest a deliberate, well-planned orchestration."
He waved her off and continued, "When I last worked the case, we had three laborers connected to the De Paul chapel construction as persons of interest that my team wasn’t able to locate. Outside of the incredibly restrictive visiting hours here, I've slipped into the Newark office and led them to believe that I'm on the case--"
"Mulder--"
He went on unheeded. "Seeing if we could track these last three men down. And I think I have my guy." His eyes were bright.
"You thought you had your man seven years ago." She was playing piggy with his toes through his sock.
He pushed his cheek out with his tongue. "You wanna hear the evidence or not?"
She watched him from under her drooping eyelids. "If you only could do a slideshow here."
He swung down his feet and started laying out photographs on her bed. "Here are the original four victims and our two new ones. I'll bet there's more out there, but these are the six we have."
She became more alert as she looked carefully at each one. "The deliberate posing--"
"Yes. But I think there's something more specific to it."
She slowly nodded. "Something..."
He waited. But she only asked, "Your suspect?"
"Jesus Montero, or at least, that's the identity that he stole in 1987 when he started working for construction companies that report to the IRS."
"Are you seeing a religious angle?"
He grinned with excitement. She was going down the same route as he for once. "Yes. I see them as saint-like figures with these poses. That was the main component of my initial profile of the killer--"
Motioning for the folder, she furrowed her brow. "Do you have a list of the dates of the deaths?"
"Right here." He reached over and flipped through until he found the right page.
"Show me one of the most recent victim's pictures."
The body was posed with the left hand raised and it was folded with the ring finger and pinkie folded to meet the thumb in the sign of a blessing.
"Just like the others…To create these elaborate poses before advanced rigor set in, he'd have to have complete privacy," she mused, "once the body was rigid, he could then place it where he wanted it to be discovered."
"My team searched for a house or building on the campus, but I wonder...A construction worker, traveling in a van?"
"I could see that. But…" she said, still looking at Rick's photo. "The date on this one?"
“January fourth."
"Damn, not what I expected."
"What do you mean?"
"That date of the Catholic calendar is for Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton."
He raised his eyebrow. “I knew you were attending church more regularly, but to the point that you have the saints days memorized?”
She wrinkled her nose at him. “Find my bag in the closet. Ritter brought my things over from my hotel.”
Mulder’s lip curled at the unfortunate agent’s name, but he retrieved her well-worn overnight bag from the hospital room’s closet.
“I should have a calendar in there,” she said, pushing her hair back from her damp forehead. “My mother gave it to me this Christmas in my stocking--“
“Don’t work on this if you’re too tired--“
“The calendar, Mulder.”
“You still get a stocking from your mom?” he asked as he carefully picked through her underwear.
“Don’t knock it until you have it,” she said, then looked sorry that she had.
Ignoring the tense moment, he found the leather-covered booklet and gave it to her. She flipped to December 1998. “When was the female victim killed?”
“December eighteenth.”
“No saint celebrated on that day.”
“The killer could still have a religious fixation without going to that depth of detail. Perhaps he kills the victim on the correct saint day,” Mulder suggested.
She shook her head slowly. “No. If he’s going to this amount of effort, I expect him to have every detail in place and it’s for public display. It’s as though he’s creating his own icons, but they can’t just be a generic saint. They have to fulfill a role.” She wasn't put off her trail. "Do you have copies of the crime scene mapping?"
He dug through Rick Bedford’s file and found the drawing from the crime scene.
Squinting at the crude map, she said, "East. The head is facing east."
"Does that mean anything?"
"Eastern Orthodox face the east to pray. Catholics don't." She lay the paper down and stared at the ceiling. "What if the dates match the Orthodox Christian Julian calendar and not the Gregorian one?"
Revitalized, he stood. “I want to check this out. Find a Julian calendar first--“
She urged him to go right then: "It's New York. You can get anything within a block of wherever you are."
He shrugged into his jacket.
"Not to rub it in, but I think I just blew away your profile again."
He straightened his tie. "What?"
"I assume Montero is Catholic. If this killer is an Eastern Orthodox follower, it's not him."
Her sly smile made his heart twist. "You haven't won yet," he murmured, leaning over to kiss her temple.
She snared his ear, holding him close for a moment. "Yes, I have," she whispered back.
The dates of all the victims did match saint days of the Eastern Orthodox calendar. However, when Mulder tracked down the two remaining stone masons, neither was practiced an Orthodox Christian faith. He typed up a report nonetheless, recommending that the entire construction crew's backgrounds be checked and sent it to the tactical team leader currently assigned to the Crucible Killer case.
Scully was transferred back to D.C. for her rehabilitation. Mulder joined her one afternoon at the physical therapist's, supposedly to be her cheering section but he just slumped on a roll of mats, chewing on the straw of his now empty soda cup and made her uncomfortable with his brooding silence.
Carefully lifting a small weight in an arm curl, she finally gave him a virtual shove. “What is it, Mulder?”
“What’s what?”
“What’s bothering you?”
“Nothin’.” The straw switched to the other side of his mouth.
“What’re you working on these days?”
He snorted. “Working…”
“What did you hear back from… Bain, was it? Agent in charge on the Crucible case?”
“Nothin’,” he repeated.
“Nothing? As in, no credit when they made the arrest?”
“Nothing as in, not a word.”
“Did you follow up?”
He glowered from under his brows. “Yes. And was told to fuck off. The pathologist assigned to the case was able to find a partial palm print on Hannah Morton’s back and they think they’re going to be able to find a match in the national database without any fancypants profile, to quote Bain directly.”
“Mulder--“
“They have the report. They have to follow up.”
They looked at each other, defeat etched on their faces.
“When do you think that you’ll be back to work?” he asked.
“Work,” she snorted. “Another week until desk duty.”
“Good. We can get back to our game of paperclip checkers.” Mulder finally smiled and she smile back.
Scully returned to work but then they received the phone call that Cassandra Spender had reappeared. The Crucible Killer case was forgotten for more important matters.
X
October 17, 2004:
Scully let Leyla Harrison into her apartment with a sense of dread.
The younger woman fought tears as she looked at Scully. "It's so wonderful to see you again, Agent...That is Doctor Scully."
"I'm happy to see you too, Agent Harrison," Scully said flatly. "It's been a long time."
Leyla stood in the middle of the studio rather than sitting anywhere. "Only a few years, but it's felt like a lifetime."
Scully decided to play dumb. "What are you doing here, Agent Harrison? Surely you haven't run across some stray receipts that you need me to code properly?"
"No, Doctor. I work out of the Richmond field office now. I've moved to research. The FBI found new uses for my encyclopedic memory."
Going to the kitchenette, Scully offered to make tea.
"That would be great. It's another cold night."
"I always called it morgue weather," Scully said as she started her electric teapot. "Mulder never even noticed, but it was the exact temperature for keeping bodies refrigerated."
Leyla bit her lower lip. "Doctor Scully, I want to extend my sympathies--"
It took Scully a moment to realize what the young agent meant. "Thank you."
"I’ve been assigned to a current case and was asked to pull all previous files. When I saw your names, it was a jolt from the past."
"A lifetime," Scully echoed as she placed two teabags in two mugs. She forced on a smile and invited Leyla to sit at the small dining table against the wall. "When were you transferred to Richmond?"
"I requested it last year. I got married, you see."
"Jeffrey?"
"Oh no. His name's Kyle." The young woman dropped her head. "He's a programmer at one of the software companies in the area. We wanted to live in a quieter place, more family-oriented..."
Of course. A young woman would want children, a house with a yard and a two car garage. Scully had thought about such things at one point of her life..."We all have to grow up sometime," Scully said briskly, moving to turn off the screaming teapot.
After placing the steaming mugs on the table, she asked, "Are you here to interview me on the Hampton case? Is that your new case?”
"I haven't been assigned to do interviews." Harrison dug through her soft-sided briefcase. "In fact, the lead investigator has been told specifically not to interview you. Orders from DC."
So Mulder wasn't the only one who was dead to the Bureau. Scully pulled the teabag from her mug and forced on a puzzled expression. "That may cost them the case. I'm a suspect with the police, after all. Surely I have some information that they can use."
"Doctor Scully, no one could suspect you--"
Scully stared unseeingly at the blank wall, her pale hands wrapped tightly around the hot mug. "Olivia Hampton found out about Agent Mulder...His death sentence...That I'd had a child and now it was gone. She put two and two together and got five. That my son had been taken away by Child Protective Services. Hardly the background a Catholic facility is looking for in a pediatrician. She could have ruined my career before it even started."
"You didn't tell her the truth?" breathed Leyla.
Scully gave a mirthless laugh. "No."
"None of that matters though. Tuttle, the agent in charge, is certain that Mrs. Hampton was killed by the Crucible Killer."
"But I'm convinced it's the husband,” said Scully. “He could have seen the other killings in the news, and patterned the murder of his wife after those," she suggested.
"No, Doctor Scully. You remember that palm print from '99?"
"Yes."
"It matched one found on her shoe. That hasn't been released to the public of course--" Leyla opened the folder and slide across two copies of palm prints.
Scully looked at them. The best fingerprint expert at the Quantico lab, Tom Slater, had signed off on the verifications.
"It can't be..." she said slowly. “I guess...” She passed a hand across her eyes. “Agent Mulder had urged that the rest of the construction crew be checked-if any were Orthodox Christians. It wasn't done in 1999...”
“No,” Leyla said, her eyes bright. “But I've done it now.”
“And?”
“Nothing,” the young agent said, her shoulders slumping. “There were two, one Ukrainian and one Lithuanian. But the Ukrainian returned to his country in 2000, and the other was permanently disabled in an accident in 1995.”
“They're both out.” Thoughtful, Scully removed the teabag from her mug.
"I'm going to leave a copy of the files," Leyla said, rising from her chair. “If you could take the time to review them and see if there's anything we're missing--”
Scully stared up at her in shock. "You can't do this, Agent Harrison. Your career--"
Leyla gave a bitter chuff. "They chose to ignore your work once before and it's allowed a killer to remain free to murder again. It's worth the risk. You left the Bureau in good standing. I trust you, Doctor Scully. I trust you to solve this case."
Scully stayed at the table, too weak to stand, as the agent let herself out of the apartment.
X
“A present for you.” Scully tossed the files on the coffee table in front of Mulder.
He started pawing through them and she turned away from the way his face lit up with excitement. She'd just become one of his secret sources.
“Who gave you these?”
“Leyla Harrison showed up today.” She explained that their work had never been followed up in 1999, and the dead end at which the case stood.
“Agent Harrison thinks that we…That I can see something that the Bureau missed,” she told him.
Mulder began to divide the papers within the folders into neat piles. “We need to start over then.”
Scully rubbed her eyes. She'd come off a twenty-four hour shift, and had given up two hours of precious sleep to bring Mulder the files. It didn't look as though any was coming her way soon. She sat at the end of the couch.
“The first victims were associated with the university,” he mused. “The New Jersey victims were not tied together in any way... But only two, then nothing until now.”
He peered up at Scully, who'd been allowing her eyelids to drift shut. “What does that spacing suggest to you?”
“Our perp has spent time in jail. Or perhaps didn't have the opportunity to stage these elaborate killings.”
He nodded. “It does require space, solitude...” He placed a crime scene photo before Scully. “Hannah Morton. The first New Jersey victim. A sales clerk in an arts supply store...”
Scully visualized the chapel on the De Paul campus. She'd visited it while attending a class last year, as though she'd somehow sensed this old case would rise again. She had examined the sculptures in the stations of the cross, done in a Byzantine style, much like Orthodox icons...
“An artist,” she suggested. “A sculptor.”
“Harrison could check the art department student list for '91, see if any happen to have criminal records--”
“Back to your original profile?”
“Wrong major though,” he grumbled.
Scully slowly pulled out her cell phone. “I'll get Harrison on it.”
She took a deep breath as she waited for the agent to pick up, preparing her performance. Fortunately, the best lies were rooted in the truth. She mentioned visiting the chapel, noticing the sculptures, and was now wondering if they’d been affixed with the same grout--perhaps the artists should be checked. All the while, Mulder hovered at her shoulder and she resisted the urge to slap him, knowing his yelp would alert Harrison.
“Doctor Scully, you’re amazing!” gushed Leyla.
“No, just a fresh set of brain cells,” Scully said, cutting off the younger woman’s enthusiasm.
“I’ll call you back as soon as soon as I have some names,” Harrison said.
Mulder was close enough to hear and his face beamed. Scully nailed him with a quelling stare. “I don’t think that’s a good idea,” she said to both Mulder and Harrison. “You should keep me out of it.”
When she hung up, she told Mulder that she was going to bed, and to have her dinner ready at five o’clock. Leaving him slumped on the couch, flipping dejectedly through the files, she went upstairs to their bed.
Of course she couldn’t sleep. Lying in the dim room, her mind kept replaying conversations with Olivia Hampton. How the woman always stood six inches too close. The way the older woman’s eager gaze held Scully’s until she was forced to look away, her skin chilled.
It had been so long since Scully had had female friends. She’d hoped in her new life that would return, but of course, in the irony of careful what you wish for, she’d been dogged by this woman’s grasping and forced intimacy. In constantly pushing her away, had Scully missed the signs of a killer in the shadows, stalking Olivia Hampton?
Olivia Hampton administered the grant which funded Scully’s position, and she’d been able to coerce Scully into attending parties and events at her home. Scully visualized the family estate that the Hamptons lived on, the deep woods around it, where a man could lurk. The many outbuildings that sat out at the edges, perfect cover for someone to observe the home. The silent servants and sullen twenty year old son, who spent as little time in Olivia’s presence as possible, not watching out for her either.
The woman’s chatter, her armor against others' contempt and indifference, washing over Scully, who had so many more important things to think about…Caught between sleep and dreams, Scully forced herself to hear Olivia’s banal chatter and actually listen to the words.
“Val in our resident artist…Val is so talented…Val will be famous someday…”
Tossing the covers aside, Scully struggled out of the bed. But when she opened the bedroom door, Mulder was hovering there, clutching the evidence file from the Hampton’s home. “Scully, did Olivia Hampton ever mention a Valentin Azarov?”
“Val. Val is a man?” Scully combed back her hair behind her ears as though to clear her mind. She didn’t even bother to note that they’d arrived at the same conclusion at the same time. They were back in the Taurus, heading down the dark road once again.
“He’s a small-time burglar that Avery Hampton represented pro bono. Recently paroled from a two year stint on a parole violation for his original sentence, served 1992 to 1998,” Mulder told her, his eyes bright with excitement.
She tugged him over to sit on the bed and took the file from him. “Any idea if he attended De Paul?”
Mulder peered over her shoulder at the paperwork that she was leafing through. “That wasn’t asked in his interview on Thursday. But he’s living on her estate in a guesthouse--“
“Yes, she mentioned him a lot but I just wasn’t listening,” Scully said with a sigh. “Yet…I can’t see how such a deliberate killer would take a victim that could be tied to him so easily--“
“I’d have Agent Harrison check him out.”
Scully pulled on her robe, then headed back downstairs to find her cell phone, Mulder in close pursuit. She tried Harrison’s work number and got her voicemail. Her cell phone had the same result. She called the work number again and after leaving a message, pressed the pound key to reach the receptionist. “I'm trying to reach Agent Harrison.”
Mulder stood close, his head cocked to listen.
“I was expecting a call from her,” Scully explained. “Is she in a meeting?” She tried to put authority in her voice, as though she may be another agent, but all the while, hearing the shake in her bad liar voice, knowing her name was showing up on caller I.D. for the operator.
“Agent Harrison is signed out for the day, ma'am,” the receptionist said blandly.
Scully hung up. “Dammit,” she growled.
“She just went home?” Mulder said, incredulous.
“No, she's gone to the Hampton estate to check on Azarov. I bet she got a hit from the student list.”
“Why would she do that instead of taking it to the lead agent?”
"Because that's what Mulder and Scully would do.”
“So what are Mulder and Scully going to do?” Mulder was already putting on his coat, answering his own question.
“Mulder, you can't come--”
“But you're going, Doctor Scully?”
She was getting her handgun from the lock box in the closet. “I can't let that girl go in with no backup--”
“Just call the police, Scully.”
She quickly loaded the weapon. “And say what? What happens when they start to look closely at Dana Scully? Find this house? And you in it?”
“I just keep getting in your way,” Mulder said, shoving his hands in his coat pockets.
She just shook her head and found a dark jacket in the closet to wear, slipping the gun in one of the pockets.
“Let me drive then.”
“You don't have a license.”
“Fine, I'll ride shotgun.”
Scully never had liked working cases without Mulder. Not that she was afraid but because he'd just always been there and knew her moves. His hand would be there to give her support when she rose from a body, or push over the locked doors. Now he could only be her ghost partner without an identity, let alone the carry permit that she had.
“Okay, but you stay in the car.”
X
When Scully pulled her car to a halt under the trees by the Hampton’s guest cottage, Mulder tried again: "Scully, I'm not just going to stay in this car--"
"I should have left you at home. Hang onto this cell phone and if necessary, dial 911.” She pressed the phone into his tense hand.
She got out of the car and leaned in through her open door. “Stay here," she repeated, low and hard.
Mulder watched her bright head bob around in the encroaching dusk, then disappear into the shrubs by the cottage, his fingers of one hand dancing on the car door handle while the other clutched the phone.
Approaching the small house, Scully checked through the windows, but it was dark and silent in that ominous way that always made the hairs stand up on the back of her neck. She considered knocking, but saw a large shed with sliding barn doors, one standing half open. She noticed a FBI issue Ford Taurus parked on the other side. Keeping her ear cocked for any movement, she checked the car, finding it empty and locked.
That just left the shed. Groping in her pockets, she found her weapon and a flashlight. Slipping the safety off on the gun, she held her the flashlight above the barrel and entered the inky darkness, snapping the light on.
“Federal agent!” she called out. The lying was coming easier and easier today.
A dozen faces stared back at her and her breath caught in her throat as she tried to cover them all at once. Busts in stone, all in the style of Byzantine icons. She was getting closer to Val. Then she heard the faint sound of a struggle coming from the back of the building. She eased between pedestals holding half-done creations in stone, their solemn eyes following her as she sought the missing agent and the killer.
“Freeze!” she barked as her cold blue light shone on two bodies brawling. One had fair hair and a high voice rasping for help. The other was larger, stronger, and huffed like a bull goring the fallen agent. But she was fighting back. In the flashlight's beam, two hands were wrestling over a gun held in one. Suddenly, it was torn free and hurled past Scully into the darkness behind her.
“Azarov, I said freeze!”
Leyla Harrison’s terrified features looked beseechingly at Scully and her mouth gaped, unable to speak. An arm was wrapped around her neck and a gun was pressed to her temple. The killer was hiding even now, lurking behind the woman's head. He peered out, and snarled, “Stop right there or I’ll kill her.”
It is not an Eastern European voice; it's the sneering drawl of Avery Hampton.
The bogeyman was in the dark, he did want pretty young women. The smooth face of the lawyer contorted and morphed, becoming Donnie Pfaster’s bland death mask, then the grimacing demon visage she’d seen right before she pulled the trigger.
She’d do it again, but she knew that she was no longer the shot that she’d once been. Her fine motor skills were being honed for another area now. The shadowed right socket of his skull was her bullseye, but Leyla’s pale face kept sliding across her vision.
“I’m sorry, Harrison,” she offered--was it that she may kill the young woman? That her hero worship was so misplaced?
Leyla panted: “Agent Scully, do what you have to do.”
“Shut up, you two bitches! No one’s gonna do anything!”
There was the roar of a gunshot and Scully blinked. Her own weapon was still cold in her hand. Harrison was falling toward her, her pretty face splattered with blood, but she was screaming, loud and true, not the gurgle of a headshot victim.
Avery was the one curling to the ground like a burning leaf, then lost in the darkness.
Scully took Leyla to her, holding her shaking body close and swung her flashlight around the black barn.
The beam found a tall man and his white face with his wide mouth in a shy smile.
"Hey Boo," Scully said, her voice shaky.
"Hey Scout," came a reply and Fox Mulder stepped out the shadows, the thrown away gun hanging at his side.
Leyla gasped, "Agent Mulder--"
He smiled down at Harrison. "Not Agent anymore. Just plain old Fox."
She thought for a long moment, then shook her head. "No, I couldn't possibly call you Fox."
"Okay, Mulder it is," he said.
"We don't have much time," said Scully, "before you need to call this in." She took the gun from Mulder and wiped it clean of his prints. "Here, let me show you how to hold your gun so the fingerprints are correct for the shot angle," she told Leyla.
Mulder was already checking Hampton’s body. “It’s going to be tough, but thankfully he’s not much taller than you, Harrison.”
“I came to check on Valentin Azarov and when there was no answer at the cottage, looked in this shed,” Harrison said, beginning to form her report already. “I found a freezer at the back--“ She motioned into the darkness.
Scully pointed her flashlight and spotlighted a large standing freezer.
“I had my own flashlight…” Obviously still in shock, Leyla looked around numbly. When she found it, she turned it back on as well, adding to the illumination.
“There’s a body in the freezer…Male, mid-thirties, resembles the mug shot for Azarov.”
Mulder moved to the freezer and after pulling his sleeve over his hand, opened it. “Looks like he’s been here about a week.”
Scully joined him. “He couldn’t have been Olivia’s killer.”
“I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t kill the other recent victims,” Mulder said. “You were right, Scully.”
“Avery killed them? To create a cover to murder his wife?”
Even though it had been her original theory, she couldn’t believe the cold-bloodedness necessary to perpetuate this sort of crime.
“We’ll let the F.B.I. pull together all the details and finally close the case,” Mulder told the women. “But Scully and I better get out of here.”
They were at the doorway when Harrison called after them. “Thank you.”
“It wasn’t anything--“ Scully started to say.
“Of course, thank you for saving my life,” Harrison said. “But thank you for giving my faith back. It’s been tough to go to work some days.”
“I know the feeling,” Mulder said with a humorless laugh. “I’m just sorry that it came to this. I let this case go too many times in the past.” He looked down at Scully. “There just seemed to always be something more important to do.”
Scully furrowed her brow, worried at his tone. “It was important, Mulder. It still is.”
Unsure, Harrison raised a hand. “I don’t suppose that I’ll see you again...”
“We’ll be here if you need our help,” Mulder assured her. “Think of us as your secret agents.” Now his laugh was filled with joy.
Scully tugged his hand. “We’ve got to go, Mulder.”
Harrison watched them walk into the darkness, swallowed by the night. The last thing she heard was, “Admit it, Mulder. You’ve always wanted to live in the Bat Cave--“
X
Leyla Harrison skimmed details of the final report on the case of Crucible Killer.
Valentin Azarov, an art student at De Paul University in 1991, was credited with murdering four fellow students. After serving a sentence for burglary, he had two more victims while living in Hoboken, New Jersey before being returned to prison on a parole violation in Richmond, Virginia when he was found loitering outside a young woman’s home in possession of burglaring tools. It’s assumed that he was targeting her for his next victim. He was represented by Avery Hampton, who was shown to have visited Azarov numerous times while he served the two year sentence. It’s believed that Azarov confessed his murders to Hampton who began to formulate a plan to murder his wife. Subsequent investigations by the local police detective, Areti, discovered Hampton had numerous profiles on websites for anonymous sexual encounters. His wife was aware of his activities and had threatened him with divorce if he did not stop.
Wanting to retain his financial and social position, Hampton planned the murder, using Azarov as a cover. After Azarov was released from prison, Hampton invited him to stay at their estate, encouraging his wife to see the artist as a protégée. Whether Hampton first tried to induce Azarov into killing his wife can’t be known. But the two murders which occurred after Azarov’s release both deviate enough from the original crimes that it’s appears that Hampton carried them out, including the death of his wife, which happened four days after Azarov’s death happened. Hampton planted the palm print on his wife’s shoe using the dead man’s hand. By retaining the body, it seems as though he planned to stage a suicide with Azarov’s body on their property, but would assure that it would not be found until decomposition was advanced enough to make pinpointing the time of death impossible.
Special Agent Leyla Harrison earned special commendation for her role in uncovering Avery Hampton’s conspiracy--
Checking over her shoulder, Leyla saw that none of the other researchers were watching her. Rising, she went to the copier and made copies of the final report. Sliding the pages into an envelope, she addressed it to Doctor Dana Scully, care of Our Lady of Sorrows Hospital. Regardless of their new lives, or the quest they were still on, she knew that Mulder and Scully would want to see the case through to the end.
~ The End
Author: bugs
Rating: T
Genre: Casefile, MSR
Word Count: 11,000
Summary: Mulder's tucked away in the country and Scully is dedicated to her new career, but one last case calls for resolution.
~*~
March 3, 1991:
"Agent Mulder, a pathologist down at Quantico has just busted your profile," William Patterson said smugly, tossing a report on Mulder's desk.
He snatched it up. "What the hell are you talking about?"
Patterson leaned on the desk's corner. "I went there myself to challenge her. She stood her ground. You know the type, one of those little girls who started applying to the FBI after Silence of the Lambs hit the bookstores."
Mulder shot his superior an unfriendly look. Sometimes Patterson acted like a man of his generation.
Four bodies had been found on or near the De Paul University campus in an eight month period, murdered by strangulation. Three women and one male, all students at the school, but with no discernible connection to each other. All laid out in a stiff, almost formal pose, flat on their backs and with special care to arranging the limbs. No sexual assault; the victims were still fully clothed.
Mulder had determined the killer was likely another student, possibly in one of the sciences with a rigid and linear outlook. The killing was secondary to the enjoyment he received from the control of possessing, moving and arranging the body. He probably had sexual dysfunction with late puberty triggering the urge to kill, but may also be an older student to have reached this level of proficiency and care.
Mulder and his small task force of two other agents had spent hours a day, seven days a week, pouring over student records. They had even found a primary suspect; Harold Schreiber, a PhD. candidate in physics, unmarried and with no personal relationships, and two juvenile arrests for arson. Mulder had interviewed him and although this did not follow the analytical protocol, found him creepy.
When the fourth body had appeared three weeks ago, it had given Mulder pause. It was a male victim. Although no sexual assault was present, he still felt the killer was displacing feelings toward women in these crimes. The female victims had all had their long hair placed carefully, almost like a wimple, and their clothes were arranged to assure that the limbs were completely covered and modest. Their eyelids were open, the eyes cast upward. The heads were tilted in such a way as to make it appear that the victims were looking heavenward. When Mulder laid the crime scene photographs out, side by side, the image that popped to mind was the Virgin Mary.
Although the latest victim had been male, he had a slight frame and shoulder length hair. It could have been mistaken identification by the killer and then faced with a dead male body, had continued with his ritual. Mulder was sticking with his profile.
But now some teaching pathologist...Mulder opened the folder with a snap...Doctor Dana Scully...had decided that the killer was a laborer of some sort.
Although all the bodies had undergone forensic examinations initially, Doctor Scully had been assigned the latest victim, Joseph Hartley, to review in one of her classes. Once she found a certain substance, she'd pulled the other victims' skin samples, looking for the same thing and had found it--powdered masonry grout; not something a physics scholar would have on his hands.
"Son of a bitch--" Mulder slapped the folder closed.
"Are you still going to pull Schreiber in?" Patterson asked, the small smile playing on his thin lips. Mulder had been his prized student but he enjoyed putting the younger man in his place when the rare opportunity arose.
"I want to talk to this Doctor Scully," Mulder grumbled. "Has she confirmed that this substance is in quantities to suggest a laborer? Maybe there's just some dust in the space where Schreiber stores the bodies before placing them to be found."
"Fox, I wanted to go over that point with you. Have you identified where Schreiber could be keeping the bodies?"
"That's why we need the search warrant," Mulder said, impatient.
"So the answer is no."
Mulder folded his arms and met his mentor's concerned gaze. "You don't feel as though I have enough to bring this guy in?"
"He lives in university housing; spends his breaks at his parents' house, but it's clear out in Pennsylvania. There's just no place to put a body."
"An empty laboratory--"
"Agents have done sweeps of all the science buildings with cadaver dogs off of your profile, Fox. No sign that human remains have been present."
"So you think that I should start looking for laborers?"
Patterson tipped his head forward.
"Fine. But I still want to check in with this Doctor Scully."
Over the next few days, Mulder played phone tag with Dana Scully, never getting more than her cool words on answering machines.
He learned that the university chapel was being remodeled on the campus. Construction had been ongoing for two years, but the finish workers had been applying stonework to the exterior for the past year. The mortar used in the work matched Doctor Scully's findings. He left one more message, grudgingly giving her that credit, but never heard anything back.
The construction had been completed the day Hartley's body had been found and the crew had dispersed. For this sort of skilled labor, few local men had been used.
Mulder and his team began to doggedly track down the men. Three were found immediately and cleared of suspicion. Three more were not. One appeared to have been an illegal Mexican immigrant using a false identity and could not be tracked.
In the next months, with no new deaths, Mulder was put on other cases which took up his time. His girlfriend Diana Fowley left him. And then he was finally assigned to the X-files section, and the Crucible Killer slipped from his consciousness.
X
January 13, 1999:
Mulder poked his head around Scully's hospital door. "You awake?"
Her eyelashes fluttered open. "If I wasn't, I am now."
Disregarding her tone, he entered and pulled a chair to her bedside.
"Bored yet?" he asked with the understanding of someone who'd been in exactly her spot too many times.
"Out of my gourd." She looked up at the muted television with discontentment. "I wish I could get into soaps."
"Who's Erica married this time?" he asked with a grin.
She ignored that. "Shouldn't you be back in DC by now? It's Wednesday.”
"Taking some vacation days," he said, rooting some sunflower seeds out of his pocket. "Not like I've got anything important going on back at headquarters." He popped a seed in his mouth.
"Personnel will be thrilled with you," she noted. "Finally using that mandatory leave."
He snagged her slack hand nearest him and twined his fingers loosely with hers. "See, you're good for something."
Blinking, she was finally able to focus clearly. "Mulder, what's that file you have with you? It's not a vacation if you've brought work with you."
"Why would I have a casefile? Not on any cases." Nonetheless, he tugged the thick folder from under his thigh.
Her rapid mind clicked. "Did you steal someone's case, Mulder?"
"Technically, it's my case. Or it was. And yours." The corner of his mouth lifted with the irony.
She settled back in the pillows. This was going to be better than a soap opera.
"In March, 1991, you shattered the profile done by a brilliant young investigator for a serial killer labeled the Crucible Killer--"
She cocked her eyebrow; no amount of opiate medication could keep it down.
"With dirt--"
"Mortar grout powder," she corrected.
"Whatever."
"Are there more victims?"
He was obviously going to take his time. He started with: "After you blew away my main suspect, I followed your lead and checked the construction workers on a campus renovation project. But the trail went cold and I--" He leaned over her hand and spoke his words like a kiss across her skin. "I...Went in another direction with my career."
"1991," she said slowly.
He straightened in the chair. "It was in part your fault."
"Me?" Her eyebrow shot back up.
"I was pissed off when I got your report. And right then I saw that profiling had become a game. It wasn't about the victims anymore but being the smartest guy in the room. I was going to come down to Quantico and kick your ass--"
"Too bad you didn't. When I saw your name on the initial report, I'd wanted to get a look at the FBI Golden Boy," she said drowsily, "heard you were hot."
He snorted. "Did you just take a hit off your pain meds pump and I didn't notice?"
She lolled her head on the pile of pillows and looked his lean body over. "I think it's remotely plausible that someone would find you hot, Agent Mulder."
Embarrassed, he slumped down in the chair. Sipping out of his shoes, he put his feet up on the bed.
She wasn't finished teasing him. "I was always surprised that you didn't mention this case when we first met. I assumed that you'd forgotten it."
"Do I forget anything?" he challenged her. "When you didn't bring it up, I thought you didn't want to talk about it, like some one night stand gone wrong."
She started to laugh, but then grimaced in pain. He stared at the ceiling rather than watch. With a groan, she rolled on her side and squeezed one of his feet.
"More bodies?" she prompted.
"Two; the most recent one last week. I wouldn't have even known, but I had some time to read the back pages of the Metro section in the Times while hanging out in the waiting room."
She made a throaty huff and rubbed her thumb along the ball of his foot. He hunched his shoulders in delight.
"Remind me of the particulars on his modus operandi," she asked.
He flipped open the file. "Victims are of both sexes, ranging in age from eighteen to thirty-one. The original four victims were all college students at De Paul University, suggesting the killer either attended or worked at the institution. The deaths stopped after the completion of a chapel restoration at the school, also suggesting a connection. That was in 1991."
He turned over a separator in the thick file. "Two new deaths, showing the same posing of the victims. Both located in Hoboken, New Jersey, just across the Hudson from New York," he said, nodding toward the window. "Hannah Morton, a twenty-seven year old clerk at an art supply store. The second victim, found last Saturday, was Rick Bedford, nineteen year old student who lived in his mother's basement. Had the same long straight hair as the sole male victim in the De Paul killings, as well as a slight frame that may be mistaken for a female if the perpetrator makes impulsive selections rather than stalking a possible victim."
Scully broke in, "But the crimes suggest a deliberate, well-planned orchestration."
He waved her off and continued, "When I last worked the case, we had three laborers connected to the De Paul chapel construction as persons of interest that my team wasn’t able to locate. Outside of the incredibly restrictive visiting hours here, I've slipped into the Newark office and led them to believe that I'm on the case--"
"Mulder--"
He went on unheeded. "Seeing if we could track these last three men down. And I think I have my guy." His eyes were bright.
"You thought you had your man seven years ago." She was playing piggy with his toes through his sock.
He pushed his cheek out with his tongue. "You wanna hear the evidence or not?"
She watched him from under her drooping eyelids. "If you only could do a slideshow here."
He swung down his feet and started laying out photographs on her bed. "Here are the original four victims and our two new ones. I'll bet there's more out there, but these are the six we have."
She became more alert as she looked carefully at each one. "The deliberate posing--"
"Yes. But I think there's something more specific to it."
She slowly nodded. "Something..."
He waited. But she only asked, "Your suspect?"
"Jesus Montero, or at least, that's the identity that he stole in 1987 when he started working for construction companies that report to the IRS."
"Are you seeing a religious angle?"
He grinned with excitement. She was going down the same route as he for once. "Yes. I see them as saint-like figures with these poses. That was the main component of my initial profile of the killer--"
Motioning for the folder, she furrowed her brow. "Do you have a list of the dates of the deaths?"
"Right here." He reached over and flipped through until he found the right page.
"Show me one of the most recent victim's pictures."
The body was posed with the left hand raised and it was folded with the ring finger and pinkie folded to meet the thumb in the sign of a blessing.
"Just like the others…To create these elaborate poses before advanced rigor set in, he'd have to have complete privacy," she mused, "once the body was rigid, he could then place it where he wanted it to be discovered."
"My team searched for a house or building on the campus, but I wonder...A construction worker, traveling in a van?"
"I could see that. But…" she said, still looking at Rick's photo. "The date on this one?"
“January fourth."
"Damn, not what I expected."
"What do you mean?"
"That date of the Catholic calendar is for Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton."
He raised his eyebrow. “I knew you were attending church more regularly, but to the point that you have the saints days memorized?”
She wrinkled her nose at him. “Find my bag in the closet. Ritter brought my things over from my hotel.”
Mulder’s lip curled at the unfortunate agent’s name, but he retrieved her well-worn overnight bag from the hospital room’s closet.
“I should have a calendar in there,” she said, pushing her hair back from her damp forehead. “My mother gave it to me this Christmas in my stocking--“
“Don’t work on this if you’re too tired--“
“The calendar, Mulder.”
“You still get a stocking from your mom?” he asked as he carefully picked through her underwear.
“Don’t knock it until you have it,” she said, then looked sorry that she had.
Ignoring the tense moment, he found the leather-covered booklet and gave it to her. She flipped to December 1998. “When was the female victim killed?”
“December eighteenth.”
“No saint celebrated on that day.”
“The killer could still have a religious fixation without going to that depth of detail. Perhaps he kills the victim on the correct saint day,” Mulder suggested.
She shook her head slowly. “No. If he’s going to this amount of effort, I expect him to have every detail in place and it’s for public display. It’s as though he’s creating his own icons, but they can’t just be a generic saint. They have to fulfill a role.” She wasn't put off her trail. "Do you have copies of the crime scene mapping?"
He dug through Rick Bedford’s file and found the drawing from the crime scene.
Squinting at the crude map, she said, "East. The head is facing east."
"Does that mean anything?"
"Eastern Orthodox face the east to pray. Catholics don't." She lay the paper down and stared at the ceiling. "What if the dates match the Orthodox Christian Julian calendar and not the Gregorian one?"
Revitalized, he stood. “I want to check this out. Find a Julian calendar first--“
She urged him to go right then: "It's New York. You can get anything within a block of wherever you are."
He shrugged into his jacket.
"Not to rub it in, but I think I just blew away your profile again."
He straightened his tie. "What?"
"I assume Montero is Catholic. If this killer is an Eastern Orthodox follower, it's not him."
Her sly smile made his heart twist. "You haven't won yet," he murmured, leaning over to kiss her temple.
She snared his ear, holding him close for a moment. "Yes, I have," she whispered back.
The dates of all the victims did match saint days of the Eastern Orthodox calendar. However, when Mulder tracked down the two remaining stone masons, neither was practiced an Orthodox Christian faith. He typed up a report nonetheless, recommending that the entire construction crew's backgrounds be checked and sent it to the tactical team leader currently assigned to the Crucible Killer case.
Scully was transferred back to D.C. for her rehabilitation. Mulder joined her one afternoon at the physical therapist's, supposedly to be her cheering section but he just slumped on a roll of mats, chewing on the straw of his now empty soda cup and made her uncomfortable with his brooding silence.
Carefully lifting a small weight in an arm curl, she finally gave him a virtual shove. “What is it, Mulder?”
“What’s what?”
“What’s bothering you?”
“Nothin’.” The straw switched to the other side of his mouth.
“What’re you working on these days?”
He snorted. “Working…”
“What did you hear back from… Bain, was it? Agent in charge on the Crucible case?”
“Nothin’,” he repeated.
“Nothing? As in, no credit when they made the arrest?”
“Nothing as in, not a word.”
“Did you follow up?”
He glowered from under his brows. “Yes. And was told to fuck off. The pathologist assigned to the case was able to find a partial palm print on Hannah Morton’s back and they think they’re going to be able to find a match in the national database without any fancypants profile, to quote Bain directly.”
“Mulder--“
“They have the report. They have to follow up.”
They looked at each other, defeat etched on their faces.
“When do you think that you’ll be back to work?” he asked.
“Work,” she snorted. “Another week until desk duty.”
“Good. We can get back to our game of paperclip checkers.” Mulder finally smiled and she smile back.
Scully returned to work but then they received the phone call that Cassandra Spender had reappeared. The Crucible Killer case was forgotten for more important matters.
X
October 17, 2004:
Scully let Leyla Harrison into her apartment with a sense of dread.
The younger woman fought tears as she looked at Scully. "It's so wonderful to see you again, Agent...That is Doctor Scully."
"I'm happy to see you too, Agent Harrison," Scully said flatly. "It's been a long time."
Leyla stood in the middle of the studio rather than sitting anywhere. "Only a few years, but it's felt like a lifetime."
Scully decided to play dumb. "What are you doing here, Agent Harrison? Surely you haven't run across some stray receipts that you need me to code properly?"
"No, Doctor. I work out of the Richmond field office now. I've moved to research. The FBI found new uses for my encyclopedic memory."
Going to the kitchenette, Scully offered to make tea.
"That would be great. It's another cold night."
"I always called it morgue weather," Scully said as she started her electric teapot. "Mulder never even noticed, but it was the exact temperature for keeping bodies refrigerated."
Leyla bit her lower lip. "Doctor Scully, I want to extend my sympathies--"
It took Scully a moment to realize what the young agent meant. "Thank you."
"I’ve been assigned to a current case and was asked to pull all previous files. When I saw your names, it was a jolt from the past."
"A lifetime," Scully echoed as she placed two teabags in two mugs. She forced on a smile and invited Leyla to sit at the small dining table against the wall. "When were you transferred to Richmond?"
"I requested it last year. I got married, you see."
"Jeffrey?"
"Oh no. His name's Kyle." The young woman dropped her head. "He's a programmer at one of the software companies in the area. We wanted to live in a quieter place, more family-oriented..."
Of course. A young woman would want children, a house with a yard and a two car garage. Scully had thought about such things at one point of her life..."We all have to grow up sometime," Scully said briskly, moving to turn off the screaming teapot.
After placing the steaming mugs on the table, she asked, "Are you here to interview me on the Hampton case? Is that your new case?”
"I haven't been assigned to do interviews." Harrison dug through her soft-sided briefcase. "In fact, the lead investigator has been told specifically not to interview you. Orders from DC."
So Mulder wasn't the only one who was dead to the Bureau. Scully pulled the teabag from her mug and forced on a puzzled expression. "That may cost them the case. I'm a suspect with the police, after all. Surely I have some information that they can use."
"Doctor Scully, no one could suspect you--"
Scully stared unseeingly at the blank wall, her pale hands wrapped tightly around the hot mug. "Olivia Hampton found out about Agent Mulder...His death sentence...That I'd had a child and now it was gone. She put two and two together and got five. That my son had been taken away by Child Protective Services. Hardly the background a Catholic facility is looking for in a pediatrician. She could have ruined my career before it even started."
"You didn't tell her the truth?" breathed Leyla.
Scully gave a mirthless laugh. "No."
"None of that matters though. Tuttle, the agent in charge, is certain that Mrs. Hampton was killed by the Crucible Killer."
"But I'm convinced it's the husband,” said Scully. “He could have seen the other killings in the news, and patterned the murder of his wife after those," she suggested.
"No, Doctor Scully. You remember that palm print from '99?"
"Yes."
"It matched one found on her shoe. That hasn't been released to the public of course--" Leyla opened the folder and slide across two copies of palm prints.
Scully looked at them. The best fingerprint expert at the Quantico lab, Tom Slater, had signed off on the verifications.
"It can't be..." she said slowly. “I guess...” She passed a hand across her eyes. “Agent Mulder had urged that the rest of the construction crew be checked-if any were Orthodox Christians. It wasn't done in 1999...”
“No,” Leyla said, her eyes bright. “But I've done it now.”
“And?”
“Nothing,” the young agent said, her shoulders slumping. “There were two, one Ukrainian and one Lithuanian. But the Ukrainian returned to his country in 2000, and the other was permanently disabled in an accident in 1995.”
“They're both out.” Thoughtful, Scully removed the teabag from her mug.
"I'm going to leave a copy of the files," Leyla said, rising from her chair. “If you could take the time to review them and see if there's anything we're missing--”
Scully stared up at her in shock. "You can't do this, Agent Harrison. Your career--"
Leyla gave a bitter chuff. "They chose to ignore your work once before and it's allowed a killer to remain free to murder again. It's worth the risk. You left the Bureau in good standing. I trust you, Doctor Scully. I trust you to solve this case."
Scully stayed at the table, too weak to stand, as the agent let herself out of the apartment.
X
“A present for you.” Scully tossed the files on the coffee table in front of Mulder.
He started pawing through them and she turned away from the way his face lit up with excitement. She'd just become one of his secret sources.
“Who gave you these?”
“Leyla Harrison showed up today.” She explained that their work had never been followed up in 1999, and the dead end at which the case stood.
“Agent Harrison thinks that we…That I can see something that the Bureau missed,” she told him.
Mulder began to divide the papers within the folders into neat piles. “We need to start over then.”
Scully rubbed her eyes. She'd come off a twenty-four hour shift, and had given up two hours of precious sleep to bring Mulder the files. It didn't look as though any was coming her way soon. She sat at the end of the couch.
“The first victims were associated with the university,” he mused. “The New Jersey victims were not tied together in any way... But only two, then nothing until now.”
He peered up at Scully, who'd been allowing her eyelids to drift shut. “What does that spacing suggest to you?”
“Our perp has spent time in jail. Or perhaps didn't have the opportunity to stage these elaborate killings.”
He nodded. “It does require space, solitude...” He placed a crime scene photo before Scully. “Hannah Morton. The first New Jersey victim. A sales clerk in an arts supply store...”
Scully visualized the chapel on the De Paul campus. She'd visited it while attending a class last year, as though she'd somehow sensed this old case would rise again. She had examined the sculptures in the stations of the cross, done in a Byzantine style, much like Orthodox icons...
“An artist,” she suggested. “A sculptor.”
“Harrison could check the art department student list for '91, see if any happen to have criminal records--”
“Back to your original profile?”
“Wrong major though,” he grumbled.
Scully slowly pulled out her cell phone. “I'll get Harrison on it.”
She took a deep breath as she waited for the agent to pick up, preparing her performance. Fortunately, the best lies were rooted in the truth. She mentioned visiting the chapel, noticing the sculptures, and was now wondering if they’d been affixed with the same grout--perhaps the artists should be checked. All the while, Mulder hovered at her shoulder and she resisted the urge to slap him, knowing his yelp would alert Harrison.
“Doctor Scully, you’re amazing!” gushed Leyla.
“No, just a fresh set of brain cells,” Scully said, cutting off the younger woman’s enthusiasm.
“I’ll call you back as soon as soon as I have some names,” Harrison said.
Mulder was close enough to hear and his face beamed. Scully nailed him with a quelling stare. “I don’t think that’s a good idea,” she said to both Mulder and Harrison. “You should keep me out of it.”
When she hung up, she told Mulder that she was going to bed, and to have her dinner ready at five o’clock. Leaving him slumped on the couch, flipping dejectedly through the files, she went upstairs to their bed.
Of course she couldn’t sleep. Lying in the dim room, her mind kept replaying conversations with Olivia Hampton. How the woman always stood six inches too close. The way the older woman’s eager gaze held Scully’s until she was forced to look away, her skin chilled.
It had been so long since Scully had had female friends. She’d hoped in her new life that would return, but of course, in the irony of careful what you wish for, she’d been dogged by this woman’s grasping and forced intimacy. In constantly pushing her away, had Scully missed the signs of a killer in the shadows, stalking Olivia Hampton?
Olivia Hampton administered the grant which funded Scully’s position, and she’d been able to coerce Scully into attending parties and events at her home. Scully visualized the family estate that the Hamptons lived on, the deep woods around it, where a man could lurk. The many outbuildings that sat out at the edges, perfect cover for someone to observe the home. The silent servants and sullen twenty year old son, who spent as little time in Olivia’s presence as possible, not watching out for her either.
The woman’s chatter, her armor against others' contempt and indifference, washing over Scully, who had so many more important things to think about…Caught between sleep and dreams, Scully forced herself to hear Olivia’s banal chatter and actually listen to the words.
“Val in our resident artist…Val is so talented…Val will be famous someday…”
Tossing the covers aside, Scully struggled out of the bed. But when she opened the bedroom door, Mulder was hovering there, clutching the evidence file from the Hampton’s home. “Scully, did Olivia Hampton ever mention a Valentin Azarov?”
“Val. Val is a man?” Scully combed back her hair behind her ears as though to clear her mind. She didn’t even bother to note that they’d arrived at the same conclusion at the same time. They were back in the Taurus, heading down the dark road once again.
“He’s a small-time burglar that Avery Hampton represented pro bono. Recently paroled from a two year stint on a parole violation for his original sentence, served 1992 to 1998,” Mulder told her, his eyes bright with excitement.
She tugged him over to sit on the bed and took the file from him. “Any idea if he attended De Paul?”
Mulder peered over her shoulder at the paperwork that she was leafing through. “That wasn’t asked in his interview on Thursday. But he’s living on her estate in a guesthouse--“
“Yes, she mentioned him a lot but I just wasn’t listening,” Scully said with a sigh. “Yet…I can’t see how such a deliberate killer would take a victim that could be tied to him so easily--“
“I’d have Agent Harrison check him out.”
Scully pulled on her robe, then headed back downstairs to find her cell phone, Mulder in close pursuit. She tried Harrison’s work number and got her voicemail. Her cell phone had the same result. She called the work number again and after leaving a message, pressed the pound key to reach the receptionist. “I'm trying to reach Agent Harrison.”
Mulder stood close, his head cocked to listen.
“I was expecting a call from her,” Scully explained. “Is she in a meeting?” She tried to put authority in her voice, as though she may be another agent, but all the while, hearing the shake in her bad liar voice, knowing her name was showing up on caller I.D. for the operator.
“Agent Harrison is signed out for the day, ma'am,” the receptionist said blandly.
Scully hung up. “Dammit,” she growled.
“She just went home?” Mulder said, incredulous.
“No, she's gone to the Hampton estate to check on Azarov. I bet she got a hit from the student list.”
“Why would she do that instead of taking it to the lead agent?”
"Because that's what Mulder and Scully would do.”
“So what are Mulder and Scully going to do?” Mulder was already putting on his coat, answering his own question.
“Mulder, you can't come--”
“But you're going, Doctor Scully?”
She was getting her handgun from the lock box in the closet. “I can't let that girl go in with no backup--”
“Just call the police, Scully.”
She quickly loaded the weapon. “And say what? What happens when they start to look closely at Dana Scully? Find this house? And you in it?”
“I just keep getting in your way,” Mulder said, shoving his hands in his coat pockets.
She just shook her head and found a dark jacket in the closet to wear, slipping the gun in one of the pockets.
“Let me drive then.”
“You don't have a license.”
“Fine, I'll ride shotgun.”
Scully never had liked working cases without Mulder. Not that she was afraid but because he'd just always been there and knew her moves. His hand would be there to give her support when she rose from a body, or push over the locked doors. Now he could only be her ghost partner without an identity, let alone the carry permit that she had.
“Okay, but you stay in the car.”
X
When Scully pulled her car to a halt under the trees by the Hampton’s guest cottage, Mulder tried again: "Scully, I'm not just going to stay in this car--"
"I should have left you at home. Hang onto this cell phone and if necessary, dial 911.” She pressed the phone into his tense hand.
She got out of the car and leaned in through her open door. “Stay here," she repeated, low and hard.
Mulder watched her bright head bob around in the encroaching dusk, then disappear into the shrubs by the cottage, his fingers of one hand dancing on the car door handle while the other clutched the phone.
Approaching the small house, Scully checked through the windows, but it was dark and silent in that ominous way that always made the hairs stand up on the back of her neck. She considered knocking, but saw a large shed with sliding barn doors, one standing half open. She noticed a FBI issue Ford Taurus parked on the other side. Keeping her ear cocked for any movement, she checked the car, finding it empty and locked.
That just left the shed. Groping in her pockets, she found her weapon and a flashlight. Slipping the safety off on the gun, she held her the flashlight above the barrel and entered the inky darkness, snapping the light on.
“Federal agent!” she called out. The lying was coming easier and easier today.
A dozen faces stared back at her and her breath caught in her throat as she tried to cover them all at once. Busts in stone, all in the style of Byzantine icons. She was getting closer to Val. Then she heard the faint sound of a struggle coming from the back of the building. She eased between pedestals holding half-done creations in stone, their solemn eyes following her as she sought the missing agent and the killer.
“Freeze!” she barked as her cold blue light shone on two bodies brawling. One had fair hair and a high voice rasping for help. The other was larger, stronger, and huffed like a bull goring the fallen agent. But she was fighting back. In the flashlight's beam, two hands were wrestling over a gun held in one. Suddenly, it was torn free and hurled past Scully into the darkness behind her.
“Azarov, I said freeze!”
Leyla Harrison’s terrified features looked beseechingly at Scully and her mouth gaped, unable to speak. An arm was wrapped around her neck and a gun was pressed to her temple. The killer was hiding even now, lurking behind the woman's head. He peered out, and snarled, “Stop right there or I’ll kill her.”
It is not an Eastern European voice; it's the sneering drawl of Avery Hampton.
The bogeyman was in the dark, he did want pretty young women. The smooth face of the lawyer contorted and morphed, becoming Donnie Pfaster’s bland death mask, then the grimacing demon visage she’d seen right before she pulled the trigger.
She’d do it again, but she knew that she was no longer the shot that she’d once been. Her fine motor skills were being honed for another area now. The shadowed right socket of his skull was her bullseye, but Leyla’s pale face kept sliding across her vision.
“I’m sorry, Harrison,” she offered--was it that she may kill the young woman? That her hero worship was so misplaced?
Leyla panted: “Agent Scully, do what you have to do.”
“Shut up, you two bitches! No one’s gonna do anything!”
There was the roar of a gunshot and Scully blinked. Her own weapon was still cold in her hand. Harrison was falling toward her, her pretty face splattered with blood, but she was screaming, loud and true, not the gurgle of a headshot victim.
Avery was the one curling to the ground like a burning leaf, then lost in the darkness.
Scully took Leyla to her, holding her shaking body close and swung her flashlight around the black barn.
The beam found a tall man and his white face with his wide mouth in a shy smile.
"Hey Boo," Scully said, her voice shaky.
"Hey Scout," came a reply and Fox Mulder stepped out the shadows, the thrown away gun hanging at his side.
Leyla gasped, "Agent Mulder--"
He smiled down at Harrison. "Not Agent anymore. Just plain old Fox."
She thought for a long moment, then shook her head. "No, I couldn't possibly call you Fox."
"Okay, Mulder it is," he said.
"We don't have much time," said Scully, "before you need to call this in." She took the gun from Mulder and wiped it clean of his prints. "Here, let me show you how to hold your gun so the fingerprints are correct for the shot angle," she told Leyla.
Mulder was already checking Hampton’s body. “It’s going to be tough, but thankfully he’s not much taller than you, Harrison.”
“I came to check on Valentin Azarov and when there was no answer at the cottage, looked in this shed,” Harrison said, beginning to form her report already. “I found a freezer at the back--“ She motioned into the darkness.
Scully pointed her flashlight and spotlighted a large standing freezer.
“I had my own flashlight…” Obviously still in shock, Leyla looked around numbly. When she found it, she turned it back on as well, adding to the illumination.
“There’s a body in the freezer…Male, mid-thirties, resembles the mug shot for Azarov.”
Mulder moved to the freezer and after pulling his sleeve over his hand, opened it. “Looks like he’s been here about a week.”
Scully joined him. “He couldn’t have been Olivia’s killer.”
“I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t kill the other recent victims,” Mulder said. “You were right, Scully.”
“Avery killed them? To create a cover to murder his wife?”
Even though it had been her original theory, she couldn’t believe the cold-bloodedness necessary to perpetuate this sort of crime.
“We’ll let the F.B.I. pull together all the details and finally close the case,” Mulder told the women. “But Scully and I better get out of here.”
They were at the doorway when Harrison called after them. “Thank you.”
“It wasn’t anything--“ Scully started to say.
“Of course, thank you for saving my life,” Harrison said. “But thank you for giving my faith back. It’s been tough to go to work some days.”
“I know the feeling,” Mulder said with a humorless laugh. “I’m just sorry that it came to this. I let this case go too many times in the past.” He looked down at Scully. “There just seemed to always be something more important to do.”
Scully furrowed her brow, worried at his tone. “It was important, Mulder. It still is.”
Unsure, Harrison raised a hand. “I don’t suppose that I’ll see you again...”
“We’ll be here if you need our help,” Mulder assured her. “Think of us as your secret agents.” Now his laugh was filled with joy.
Scully tugged his hand. “We’ve got to go, Mulder.”
Harrison watched them walk into the darkness, swallowed by the night. The last thing she heard was, “Admit it, Mulder. You’ve always wanted to live in the Bat Cave--“
X
Leyla Harrison skimmed details of the final report on the case of Crucible Killer.
Valentin Azarov, an art student at De Paul University in 1991, was credited with murdering four fellow students. After serving a sentence for burglary, he had two more victims while living in Hoboken, New Jersey before being returned to prison on a parole violation in Richmond, Virginia when he was found loitering outside a young woman’s home in possession of burglaring tools. It’s assumed that he was targeting her for his next victim. He was represented by Avery Hampton, who was shown to have visited Azarov numerous times while he served the two year sentence. It’s believed that Azarov confessed his murders to Hampton who began to formulate a plan to murder his wife. Subsequent investigations by the local police detective, Areti, discovered Hampton had numerous profiles on websites for anonymous sexual encounters. His wife was aware of his activities and had threatened him with divorce if he did not stop.
Wanting to retain his financial and social position, Hampton planned the murder, using Azarov as a cover. After Azarov was released from prison, Hampton invited him to stay at their estate, encouraging his wife to see the artist as a protégée. Whether Hampton first tried to induce Azarov into killing his wife can’t be known. But the two murders which occurred after Azarov’s release both deviate enough from the original crimes that it’s appears that Hampton carried them out, including the death of his wife, which happened four days after Azarov’s death happened. Hampton planted the palm print on his wife’s shoe using the dead man’s hand. By retaining the body, it seems as though he planned to stage a suicide with Azarov’s body on their property, but would assure that it would not be found until decomposition was advanced enough to make pinpointing the time of death impossible.
Special Agent Leyla Harrison earned special commendation for her role in uncovering Avery Hampton’s conspiracy--
Checking over her shoulder, Leyla saw that none of the other researchers were watching her. Rising, she went to the copier and made copies of the final report. Sliding the pages into an envelope, she addressed it to Doctor Dana Scully, care of Our Lady of Sorrows Hospital. Regardless of their new lives, or the quest they were still on, she knew that Mulder and Scully would want to see the case through to the end.
~ The End