Okay, so I'm dumb.
I more or less posted this last week, but managed to somehow overwrite it with the one I made today. Thankfully, I had an extra copy saved somewhere that contained most of it, as this is the way I keep track of my favorites these days. Some stories are missing, but most of it should be here.
Hope there's something you're interested in on either list. :)
Spn Gen
And I Won’t Sympathise Anymore by
fleshflutterSam gets a call from Dean while at a bar, hearing gunshots in the background.
- Very human, in touch with Sam's whole Stanford-era, "I don't want to care, but I secretly do," vibe. Twist at the end.
And to All a Good Night by
veronamaySam's a little drunk. Dean's sleepy. There's cuddling.
- It's Sam/Dean, rated G, but it can easily be read as Gen as well. Cuddling wins every time and this is well-written on top of it all.
Artic Radar by
musesfoolSam knew there were lots of things he still didn't know about Dean. The past two and a half years had been full of startling revelations, and this was possibly the most startling of all.
- Dean's new hobby is hilarious and Sam's reaction is even better. Aside from that, I really like the dynamics in this. The giving-Dean vs. understatedly gracious-Sam.
Because It's Christmas by
ficwriter1966“Where did you get all this?” John asked, not sure he wanted to know the answer. The boy had never admitted to it, but thanks to Sam’s occasionally less than discreet sensibilities, John knew Dean had more than once pilfered what he thought he needed to spruce up Sam’s Christmas. And somehow, Christmas and thievery didn’t seem to go together.
- One of those "Oh Dean" interactions between father and son, because Dean just tries so hard.
Cartography in Empty Spaces by
ignipesDean has been gone for two years. On Christmas Day, an old friend brings him back to Sam's doorstep.
- Heartbreaking and hard to read, with an ending that leaves it open for hope.
Cheap Thrills by
halfshellvenusThere's a reason why they still make those Magic Fingers beds…
- Short and cute. Dean drags Sam over to the darkside.
Cracked by
whereuponIt's not about him. It's about Sam.
- Asylum is one of my favorite episodes for tags, but so many out there are just clones of others. This one is refreshing.
Credence by
bellatempleThe story of an amulet in three scenes.
- Amulet fic where Sam justifies giving Dean the amulet instead of John, "I'd rather the monsters get Dad than Dean," which is proven to translate directly into, "Good story."
Five Postcards Dean Didn't Send by
eloise_bright- Title says it all, really. Looking through the trunk of the Impala, Sam finds some postcards that Dean wrote to him during the Stanford era but never sent. Pulls at the heartstrings, good voice for Dean in this as well.
A Good Man is Hard to Find by
kimonkey7Dean keeps his word, and ramifications scatter like salt shot. Secrets, liquor, and bad things.
- Stories about addiction draw me in and keep me there, though this one is so much more than that. I read this all in one setting.
I Am Not Now, Nor Have I Ever Been by
dotficAttending a new school in March, the boys pretend to be unrelated until June.
- The premise is interesting and different, yet still quite plausible.
Man's Best Friend by
sarah_pDean totally has a LiveJournal.
- One of the few stories I've seen that can actually pull of the whole Livejournal thing, and make a good story out of it to boot.
The Measure of a Man by
kroki_refurThey’re running out of time, and Sam’s only got one idea left.
- Painful and adorable, because, really, who can resist a Dean-worshipping little Sammy and an anything-to-save-Dean big one?
My Red Thoughts in a Red Shade by
smilla02One day you finally knew what you had to do.
- One of those Dean comes back from hell-type stories. I think... very different from the usual.
The Naked Floor Reminds Me by
musesfoolTop Five Memories Sam has of growing up with Dean: the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.
- Vague hero worship on Sam's part and realistic snapshots of the two of them growing up.
Raising the Dead by
esteiSam comes home.
- Possibly one of the most intriguing, original fics I have ever read. It's going along, then suddenly she throws a twist in there that makes you go, "... What?" but in a good way. Just amazing and original.
Sounds You'll Sleep Through by
trollprincessSam's first week at college isn't only hard on him.
- Adorable fic. After Sam goes to college, Dean gets a dog and names it Sammy. Or does he? Original and cute.
Summer Camp by
gigglingkat"I sent his brother to summer camp," he explained. "You heartless bastard," laughed the manager. "That seems to be the general consensus," John agreed.
- Because Little Sammy missing Little Dean is just too adorable to resist.
Swing Low by
sevenfists (PG-13)
What's dead should stay dead.
- One of my favorites. The dynamics are just so good.
Things Sam Has Not Missed About This Life by
cupiscentLike it says - ten things Sam hasn't missed about this life, and one thing he has.
- Great story that is very Sam and an ending that leaves you smiling. Grinning, even.
Sam/Dean
Green and Gamboge by
sevenfists (R)
Some gremlins adopt Dean and Sam can’t help but feel jealous of the attention his brother pays them.
- This is one of those stories I’d seen on about every rec list I’ve ever visited, but for some reason never got around to reading. Now I understand completely why it had been on every rec list ever.
I Got Me a Nice Little Place in the Stars by
luzdeestrellas (PG)
Sam ran away from everything life as a Winchester promised, trying to find his place in the world, but when Dean showed up at his door, needing a place to stay, he realized that without Dean, no place was home
- One of my favorites; any story that has Dean saying, "The name's Dean. I used to change your diapers and tuck you in at night; I don't know if you remember," is pretty much proven to win me over.
In the Cold by
bitchandjerk (R)
A year after Dean's death Sam is finally ready to move on
… Only he doesn’t have to. Love, love, love this.
Life as We Know It by
sevenfists (R)
Our boys buy curtains and fall in love.
- Domestic schmoop adorableness paired with her standard well-written plot.
RPS
Big Yellow Taste by
indysaurEndings are hard. Beginnings are harder. Supernatural wraps up and Jared and Jensen approach the next year in radically different fashion.
- The after-Supernatural concept is my favorite and this is just so cute. Plus second chapter is really cool- actual postcards. Multimedia.
Sick Verse by
writeatmidnightStarted with, "Who would have guessed that watching someone heave their lunch into a wastebasket could make you realize that, hey, maybe you have a thing for them," evolved into their imperfect, yet still amazing romance.
- This is my favorite, hands down. So many of the J2 fics out there are all about the sex, two seconds in, which doesn't serve the boys justice. This one, however, is paced so beautifully, handled so gracefully with so much realistic care, that it pans out into an absolutely gorgeous saga. Love this.
The Jared Padalecki Project by
esohpeAfter Supernatural, Jensen and Jared aren't talking. But a film's a film and Jensen could really use the money.
- Beautiful concept, great progression with a heartbreakingly persistant Jared and a Jensen that's trying as hard as he can to hate him. Pacing is perfect and it addresses all the questions you had in the beginning, but in its own time.