(no subject)
VOTED OFF
by gahdzuks
by shizukuchan
Thanks for your entry, hope you stick around for future votings and then sign up again for the next round :)
If you want a banner (4th place) let me know in a comment^^
The entries again:
001
002
003
004
the voting results:
01. -1
02. -1
03. -6
04. -4
the reasons given for the votes:
01. negative: 1
- Not enough contrast, the sky template seems out of place, text is too light.
extra comments:
I like 001-it's very original :)
I relaly like 1 :) very cool :)
02. negative: 1
- The picture used, at icon size, is not really recognizable as David Tennant. And the microtext used is unreadable.
extra comments:
And I know we don't vote for the most awesome this time, but I have to say #002 cracks me up.
from another comment: (2 is fantastic with that swoopy thing, I love that)
03. negative: 6
- The font doesn't complement the icon
- It seems pretty simple, by appearances just an edited black-and-white image with a texture and some text added. All three of the others seem to have included a little more work, with positioning and texture manipulation (2 is fantastic with that swoopy thing, I love that). In comparison, this one seems kind of bland. In addition, the texture seems to obscure the icon, so that if I didn't know better I'd think it was just a really low-quality picture.
- text placement makes it kinda difficutl to read. The words in the dead center of the icon are getting lost.
- The grey fuzzy texture in the icon looks strange and overpowers the entire icon
- it seems like there's not much done to the original image
- blurry, unflattering font
04. negative: 4
- The colors in the texture do not really work well with the image used, the text is difficult to read, and the image itself could fit the textual description better (meaning he could look a little crazier).
- The texture is really overpowering.
- slightly oversharpened and patchy in places where David has been cut out (you can see white around the edges)
- the icon seems over-sharpened
the new challenge will be posted later tonight^^