Leave a comment

pinguthegreek January 30 2010, 18:20:44 UTC
I love this, but would you mind if I made a really little Britpick ?

Reply

elenopa January 30 2010, 18:29:23 UTC
You're talking about the spelling of grey aren't you?

I love it too. The ending made me cry.

Reply

pinguthegreek January 30 2010, 18:30:14 UTC
Nope, not that. It's a tiny niggle, but we don't use the word gift so much. I think Donna would call it a present.

Reply

sue_denimme January 30 2010, 19:40:13 UTC
Ah. Noted. See, that's one of the little things that's hard for an American (even one who's an Anglophile) to pick up on.

As to the spelling... I've always had a bit of a dilemma with that. I try to get the British tone down as much as possible, wording-wise, but I've got it in my head that if I also tried to spell everything the British way, it would be insulting the intelligence of British readers, especially if I betray my American-ness in some other way (like gift/present). Is that a silly concern, or should I go ahead and write "grey" and "colour" and "favourite"?

Reply

pinguthegreek January 30 2010, 19:44:23 UTC
I didn't want you to think it was a criticism. It just jarred slightly when I thought about Donna saying it. You have no idea how much I love reading your fic.

Reply

sue_denimme January 30 2010, 19:56:09 UTC
Fixed now.

I welcome criticism, of the helpful variety, so please don't hesitate to tell me when I've got something wrong. It'll save me from looking bad. :-)

Reply

pinguthegreek January 30 2010, 19:57:30 UTC
It's stuff you wouldn't know unless you were extremely used to British English. So how could you look bad ?

Reply

sue_denimme January 30 2010, 20:17:20 UTC
Aw. Well, I went ahead and changed "gray" to "grey" while I was at it.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up