Oh, New York, don't fail me now
So, you thought the death penalty articles were over, did you? Think again. This time in dear old NY.
SENATE PASSES DEATH PENALTY LEGISLATION
Legislation Would Reinstate Death Penalty for Cop Killers
Press release from the NYS State Senate
The New York State Senate today passed legislation, sponsored by Senator Martin Golden (R-C-I, Brooklyn) that will reinstate the death penalty for criminals who kill police officers. The Senate also passed a bill, sponsored by Senator Dale Volker (R-C-I, Depew) that would amend the state's death penalty law to fix a provision that was ruled invalid by the state Court of Appeals.
Senate action on the legislation was announced today at a Capitol news conference where Senate Majority Leader Joseph L. Bruno and members of the Majority Conference were joined by David and Kathy Corr, whose son Joseph Corr, a New Hartford Police Officer, was shot and killed in February while chasing a jewelry store robber.
"I have looked into the eyes of would-be cop-killers on the streets of New York City. I know that there is this evil walking on the streets of New York City, those who endanger the lives of every single New York City police officer," said Senator Marty Golden. "That is why it must be our priority to pass legislation that restores the death penalty here in New York State and makes it applicable to those who kill police officers. We can no longer sit back and watch the lives of New York's Finest be jeopardized and be cut short at the hands of hoodlums. There is no greater deterrent than the death penalty to protect our society and our police officers."
"For the Finest who have made the ultimate sacrifice, in their memory, let's protect those who survive them and who seek to insure the protection of the public, and see that justice is served in neighborhoods throughout this City," concluded Senator Golden.
"Police officers all across this state put their lives on the line every day to protect the people of New York," said Senator Bruno. "We must toughen our laws to protect police from becoming victims of violent criminals. Following the tragic killings of two New York City police officers last December, the Legislature enacted a law to increase penalties for crimes against law enforcement officials and to keep illegal guns off the streets. It's time to finish the job by reinstating the death penalty for cop killers."
The Senate passed a comprehensive bill (S.6771) would put stronger penalties in place for criminals that target police officers. The bill includes stronger penalties for assault, menacing, murder and attempted murder of an officer, as well as increased penalties for possession of armor-piercing ammunition and the reinstatement of the death penalty for criminals who kill police officers.
"Police officers deserve our unreserved support and total respect for the difficult, dangerous job they perform," Senator Raymond A. Meier (R, Western) said. "Joseph Corr made the ultimate sacrifice when he responded to a jewelry store robbery earlier this year. In addition to his job as a police officer, he was a dedicated community member, husband, and father who is sorely missed not only by his family, but the entire New Hartford community. Criminals who murder police officers strike at more than one life. By murdering one of those sworn to protect all of us they commit the ultimate offense against every citizen and society as a whole."
The Senate also passed legislation today that would amend the state's death penalty law to fix a provision that was ruled invalid by the state Court of Appeals.
"Throughout the nation, New York's capital murder statute has been known as a model that many states are utilizing as it incorporates unprecedented protections for capital defendants. It has always been a well-balanced law and it is a major reason why New York is one of the safest states in the entire country," said Senator Volker. "Yet, the New York State Court of Appeals decided that portions of our capital punishment statute needs even more protections for the defendant. That is why the State Senate will address the Court of Appeals concerns and pass legislation that will reactivate the Death Penalty. The majority of New Yorkers have consistently supported the Death Penalty and today's announcement will ensure that the ultimate sentence for the most vile will be available for prosecutors to utilize."
"The death penalty is a strong deterrent to crime. When the death penalty was reinstituted, the number of murders and violent crimes in New York decreased dramatically," said Senate Majority Leader Joseph L. Bruno. "We need to enact this bill into law to reinstitute capital punishment to prevent the murder rate from going back up."
In 2004, the Court of Appeals overturned death penalty sentences, saying that judges were improperly required to instruct jurors in capital cases that if they deadlocked and failed to reach a verdict during the penalty phase of a trial, the judge would impose a sentence that would leave the defendant eligible for parole after 20 to 25 years.
This bill (S.2727) would require that in addition to capital punishment or life in prison without parole, juries would be given a third option of imposing a sentence of life in prison with the possibility of parole when sentencing convicted murderers.
Also, the bill requires that, if a jury is deadlocked, a sentence of life without parole would be imposed, and juries would be told of that provision before sentencing. All pending capital cases, as well as crimes committed prior to the effective date of any change in the law, would be affected by the changes included in this bill.
"I urge the Assembly to bring these critically important bills to the floor," said Senator Bruno. "In 1995, 94 members of the Assembly voted in favor of death penalty legislation, and I believe these bills would pass again if brought up for a vote."
The bills were sent to the Assembly.
OK, so this is an argument that I have run into before but not really discussed much. Typically, in cases where cops are killed or injured punishments are more harsh than in a typical case. I understand that a cop killed in the line of duty is a horrible thing. Anyone killed at any point is a horrible thing. However, I still think that cops do take a certain degree of risk when they take the job. Why do we think that a cop killed in the line of duty is any different than an innocent bystander? I worry that legislation like this will just open that kind of can of worms, which is not necessarily a good thing. Furthermore, Mr. Joseph Bruno, your deterrent statement is inaccurate.
I should say, overall, I think this bill won't really get through the Assembly. However, I have always learned to never say never, especially when it comes to politics and hot button issues.
SENATE PASSES DEATH PENALTY LEGISLATION
Legislation Would Reinstate Death Penalty for Cop Killers
Press release from the NYS State Senate
The New York State Senate today passed legislation, sponsored by Senator Martin Golden (R-C-I, Brooklyn) that will reinstate the death penalty for criminals who kill police officers. The Senate also passed a bill, sponsored by Senator Dale Volker (R-C-I, Depew) that would amend the state's death penalty law to fix a provision that was ruled invalid by the state Court of Appeals.
Senate action on the legislation was announced today at a Capitol news conference where Senate Majority Leader Joseph L. Bruno and members of the Majority Conference were joined by David and Kathy Corr, whose son Joseph Corr, a New Hartford Police Officer, was shot and killed in February while chasing a jewelry store robber.
"I have looked into the eyes of would-be cop-killers on the streets of New York City. I know that there is this evil walking on the streets of New York City, those who endanger the lives of every single New York City police officer," said Senator Marty Golden. "That is why it must be our priority to pass legislation that restores the death penalty here in New York State and makes it applicable to those who kill police officers. We can no longer sit back and watch the lives of New York's Finest be jeopardized and be cut short at the hands of hoodlums. There is no greater deterrent than the death penalty to protect our society and our police officers."
"For the Finest who have made the ultimate sacrifice, in their memory, let's protect those who survive them and who seek to insure the protection of the public, and see that justice is served in neighborhoods throughout this City," concluded Senator Golden.
"Police officers all across this state put their lives on the line every day to protect the people of New York," said Senator Bruno. "We must toughen our laws to protect police from becoming victims of violent criminals. Following the tragic killings of two New York City police officers last December, the Legislature enacted a law to increase penalties for crimes against law enforcement officials and to keep illegal guns off the streets. It's time to finish the job by reinstating the death penalty for cop killers."
The Senate passed a comprehensive bill (S.6771) would put stronger penalties in place for criminals that target police officers. The bill includes stronger penalties for assault, menacing, murder and attempted murder of an officer, as well as increased penalties for possession of armor-piercing ammunition and the reinstatement of the death penalty for criminals who kill police officers.
"Police officers deserve our unreserved support and total respect for the difficult, dangerous job they perform," Senator Raymond A. Meier (R, Western) said. "Joseph Corr made the ultimate sacrifice when he responded to a jewelry store robbery earlier this year. In addition to his job as a police officer, he was a dedicated community member, husband, and father who is sorely missed not only by his family, but the entire New Hartford community. Criminals who murder police officers strike at more than one life. By murdering one of those sworn to protect all of us they commit the ultimate offense against every citizen and society as a whole."
The Senate also passed legislation today that would amend the state's death penalty law to fix a provision that was ruled invalid by the state Court of Appeals.
"Throughout the nation, New York's capital murder statute has been known as a model that many states are utilizing as it incorporates unprecedented protections for capital defendants. It has always been a well-balanced law and it is a major reason why New York is one of the safest states in the entire country," said Senator Volker. "Yet, the New York State Court of Appeals decided that portions of our capital punishment statute needs even more protections for the defendant. That is why the State Senate will address the Court of Appeals concerns and pass legislation that will reactivate the Death Penalty. The majority of New Yorkers have consistently supported the Death Penalty and today's announcement will ensure that the ultimate sentence for the most vile will be available for prosecutors to utilize."
"The death penalty is a strong deterrent to crime. When the death penalty was reinstituted, the number of murders and violent crimes in New York decreased dramatically," said Senate Majority Leader Joseph L. Bruno. "We need to enact this bill into law to reinstitute capital punishment to prevent the murder rate from going back up."
In 2004, the Court of Appeals overturned death penalty sentences, saying that judges were improperly required to instruct jurors in capital cases that if they deadlocked and failed to reach a verdict during the penalty phase of a trial, the judge would impose a sentence that would leave the defendant eligible for parole after 20 to 25 years.
This bill (S.2727) would require that in addition to capital punishment or life in prison without parole, juries would be given a third option of imposing a sentence of life in prison with the possibility of parole when sentencing convicted murderers.
Also, the bill requires that, if a jury is deadlocked, a sentence of life without parole would be imposed, and juries would be told of that provision before sentencing. All pending capital cases, as well as crimes committed prior to the effective date of any change in the law, would be affected by the changes included in this bill.
"I urge the Assembly to bring these critically important bills to the floor," said Senator Bruno. "In 1995, 94 members of the Assembly voted in favor of death penalty legislation, and I believe these bills would pass again if brought up for a vote."
The bills were sent to the Assembly.
OK, so this is an argument that I have run into before but not really discussed much. Typically, in cases where cops are killed or injured punishments are more harsh than in a typical case. I understand that a cop killed in the line of duty is a horrible thing. Anyone killed at any point is a horrible thing. However, I still think that cops do take a certain degree of risk when they take the job. Why do we think that a cop killed in the line of duty is any different than an innocent bystander? I worry that legislation like this will just open that kind of can of worms, which is not necessarily a good thing. Furthermore, Mr. Joseph Bruno, your deterrent statement is inaccurate.
I should say, overall, I think this bill won't really get through the Assembly. However, I have always learned to never say never, especially when it comes to politics and hot button issues.