I really wanted to like it. I was all prepared for much love & squee. But I...was really not impressed. Actually, I was pretty darn bored. I didn't end up caring about any of the characters. The religious issues, as well as the organized crime syndicate storyline, were not very interesting to me.
Sorry, Caprica. I loved BsG immensely, but I don't know if I'll be watching this show when it starts airing. I might give it a couple episodes to see if it picks up out of loyalty to BsG, but...meh.