Peter Wingfield.  He's utterly beautiful, incredibly talented, plays snarky brilliantly (see: Methos), has a body to die for, British/Welsh accent - and he's an actual *man*, not a boy.  He'd have been PERFECT.

Matt Smith?  Still has pimples - I'm sure the tweeners will love him, but us grown-ups, probably not so much.  Guess I'll be sticking to