Results: Round 3 // Challenge 4

Nov 05, 2009 21:10

Banner maker this week is hsapiens.

Results )

round 3.04:results, round 3, round 3.04, results

Leave a comment

Comments 59

dvshipper November 6 2009, 03:17:11 UTC
Comments for #15 please? Unscreened is fine thanks. :)

Reply

beeej November 6 2009, 04:14:06 UTC
+ 15: lovely combination of the images and gorgeous coloring; this blending looks utterly natural.

"15: Great composition."

Reply


casett November 6 2009, 03:17:33 UTC
Wheeee - still here.

Comments for #20 - just like I like it - 3 + and 3 -! Unscreened is fine.

Reply

beeej November 6 2009, 04:14:51 UTC
- 20: There is no sharpness and it's too brown ( ... )

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

beeej November 6 2009, 04:16:13 UTC
You're welcome!

+ 11: Nice contrast. The background is nice, not too busy, not too simple.
+ 11: Great use of contrast, b&w, and texture.
+ 11: The Black and white is done beautifully in this icon. Daniel is sharp without being oversharpened and the composition is just lovely.
+ 11: Lovely quality to this icon with the use of black and white, and subtle use of textures. Love the abstracting of the background.

"11: Striking b&w, love the texture and the crop. Daniel looks slightly cut off on the left, and I'm not sure if that's meant to create an illusion of him shooting from the cover of a wall, but I can go with that interpretation. In my top five icons this batch."

Reply


own_the_sky November 6 2009, 03:18:13 UTC
Comments on 9 please! Unscreened is fine Thank you!!

Reply

beeej November 6 2009, 04:16:44 UTC
- 9: The crop is interesting, but the coloring is a bit overwhelming.
- 9: Awkward blend that texture can't fix
+ 9: (Lovely crop, the colours work together well and the inlayed image of Bra'tak balances the image.)
+ 9: (The set up on the icon is great. I like how the artist have placed the characters to the icon. Also the coloring is good)
+ 9: i love this icon, the blending and colouring is done perfectly
+ 9: The coloring is fabulous, the red highlights Bra'tac very well, and the blend is excellent.

"9 : Perfect blending"
"9: Really neat blend, nicely done."

Reply


purple_dolphin9 November 6 2009, 03:28:17 UTC
Comments for 24 please, unscreened is fine thanks.

Reply

beeej November 6 2009, 04:17:17 UTC
- 24: The icon looks a bit dark, the colours seem to be washed out.
- 24: not enough contrast
- 24: The crop is unbalanced, and the coloring is very washed out.
- 24: While the crop is quite well done, sadly the icon comes across as too plain.
- 24: (the cropping is off with too much negative space on the right)
- 24: (Icon is unbalanced, there is nothing to the right of Cam and the smokey texture mutes those nice green hues of the original image.)
- 24: The cropping doesn't look right and it only reinforces Cameron blending into the background.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up