Results: Round 1 // Challenge 6
Banner maker for this challenge is chase_acow.
A word, first: We were elated to see the way icon makers stepped up to the challenge and produced an amazing array of gorgeous icons. Voting was almost impossible and many voters spontaneously commented on the difficulty in their vote. As such, we've allowed for a slightly expanded number of winners for just this challenge.
Eliminations
Sadly, we have to say goodbye to the following two users:
wiccanslyr (-16) and replicartertje (-13), respectively
Members' Choices
Congratulations to the following two users who submitted the favorites from this round:
sanami276 (+9) and wench_for_hire (+9), respectively
Mods' Choices
The following icons caught our eye:
obaona, avidrosette, txduck, and jehnt, respectively
Vote Key:
(-) = Least Favorite Vote
(+) = Most Favorite Vote
none = no votes / no comments
(+ comment) = Additional comment not included in score tally
Vote Tally:
1= +2
2= -2 + 2 = 0
3= +4 (+ comment)
4= -1
5= -1 + 9 = +8 (+ comment)
6= -1 + 4 = +3
7= -1 + 4 = +3
8= none
9= -3 + 4 = +1
10= +3 (+ comment)
11= -1 + 7 = +6
12= +3
13= -10
14= +1
15= -6 + 5 = -1
16= -2
17= +9
18= -5
19= +6 (+ comment)
20= -2 + 2 = 0
21= -13 (+ comment)
22= -5
23= +1
24= +1 (+ comment)
25= -10
26= -8 + 1 = -7
27= +2 (+ comment)
28= -1 + 4 = +3
29= +1 (+ comment)
30= +1
31= +9 (+ comment)
32= -3 + 1 = -2
33= +1
34= -2
35= -1 + 7 = +6
36= -16 (+comment)
If you would like to see your vote comments, please leave a comment here with your icon number. Indicate whether you would like your feedback in a screened or unscreened comment. Thank you!
A word, first: We were elated to see the way icon makers stepped up to the challenge and produced an amazing array of gorgeous icons. Voting was almost impossible and many voters spontaneously commented on the difficulty in their vote. As such, we've allowed for a slightly expanded number of winners for just this challenge.
Eliminations
Sadly, we have to say goodbye to the following two users:
wiccanslyr (-16) and replicartertje (-13), respectively
Members' Choices
Congratulations to the following two users who submitted the favorites from this round:
sanami276 (+9) and wench_for_hire (+9), respectively
Mods' Choices
The following icons caught our eye:
obaona, avidrosette, txduck, and jehnt, respectively
Vote Key:
(-) = Least Favorite Vote
(+) = Most Favorite Vote
none = no votes / no comments
(+ comment) = Additional comment not included in score tally
Vote Tally:
1= +2
2= -2 + 2 = 0
3= +4 (+ comment)
4= -1
5= -1 + 9 = +8 (+ comment)
6= -1 + 4 = +3
7= -1 + 4 = +3
8= none
9= -3 + 4 = +1
10= +3 (+ comment)
11= -1 + 7 = +6
12= +3
13= -10
14= +1
15= -6 + 5 = -1
16= -2
17= +9
18= -5
19= +6 (+ comment)
20= -2 + 2 = 0
21= -13 (+ comment)
22= -5
23= +1
24= +1 (+ comment)
25= -10
26= -8 + 1 = -7
27= +2 (+ comment)
28= -1 + 4 = +3
29= +1 (+ comment)
30= +1
31= +9 (+ comment)
32= -3 + 1 = -2
33= +1
34= -2
35= -1 + 7 = +6
36= -16 (+comment)
If you would like to see your vote comments, please leave a comment here with your icon number. Indicate whether you would like your feedback in a screened or unscreened comment. Thank you!