R1-C01-Results
Elimination
Well, as the voting this week turned out, we have to say goodbye to two icon makers, in the first week we are eliminating a total of 4 icons. I'm so very sorry to see you guys go so soon! I hope you guys stick around and our Challenge 07 will be our redemption round, it is a challenge in which anyone who has been previously eliminated will have the opportunity to enter and come back into the challenge.
Thank you so much for entering!
may_g
may_g
velvetgunpowder
velvetgunpowder
People's Choice
We have a tie for this week...
ladybug1219
yuppieflu
Congrats yuppieflu!! :-)
Mod's Choice
Each week I will choose an icon which I think should receive some honorable mention.
all_feeling
I will have banners for everybody made in a bit. Congrats to all the winners, and thank you so much to everyone who entered!
Voting Results
You can find your icon number here. If you don't see your icon number then that means you received no votes either way.
01: +1 -2 = -1
02: -1 -1
04: -2
05: -7
06: -2
07: -1
08: -5
09: +2 -1 = +1
10: +1
11: -1
13: -2
14: +2
15: -4
17: -8
18: +4 -2 = +2
19: -1
Negative Votes
01: bad colourisation
01: I like the coloring and the font and the placement but I've got a passionate hatred for icon borders like that.
02: I don't like repeated photos in one icon
04: Too dakr picture, I almost can't see it.
04: texture doesn't work
05: the focus of these icons I think should be on the given picture, the focus here is the text , the picture gets lost with the background.
05: the white border doesn't fit and the icon is too dark and blurred.
05: Flashing pink Comic-Sans text is a bit much
05: The animated text isn't so bad, but the image / crop / brush itself doesn't impress me
05: the animated text is a bit annoying.
05: animation does NOT work well here.
06: Too much yellow, it could have been great w/out it
07: the textures and effects are distracting
08: Awful text
08: I dislike the croping and the font.
08: what is the deal with that font? yuck!
09: Too busy for me
11: I can't really make out the writing
13: Just doesn't appear to have very much work put into it. It's mainly a cropped image with added text that looks out of place at that.
13: bad quality
15: This icon isn't very exciting, I think more could have been done to it.
15: All greyscale. Boring.
15: Not much done to it in the first place.
15: too plain
17: The icon is too dark and too purple. It could use more sharpening.
17: while i absolutly love the text, this icon is just far too purple.
17: all one colour. bit boring.
17: I dont like embossed font at all & you can hardly read the bottom font.
17: It's.. purple? Just don't favor the idea of it
17: I dont like the flood of purple all over the image & puple text on purple background.
17: purple is overpowering
18: Well, 2 members of Placebo are missing, it's not all about Brian.
Positive Votes
09: Too many textures used but the final effect is nice. Ilike the matching text.
09: great crop, mask and texture.
10: I love the warm colors & the faded fuzzy backround. the lyrics for the font are perfect and the placement is as well. Its wonderful all around.
14: I just like the way it was cropped
14: I like the simplicity and cleanliness of the image.
18: I just love the effect used on this icon, the font used is very appealing, overall very attractive icon.
18: brilliantly imaginative
18: Love the pin-up style of it... even though I have no clue what the text says, lol
18: I really love the style used.