Table of Death
This table (now completed to the end of Season Two) documents Sam and Dean's kills and associated violence. It also includes who killed the Monster of the Week (M0TW), when that was not Sam or Dean.
This is not a definitive science so feel free to dispute my classifications or add ones I’ve missed. In some cases you could argue that Sam and/or Dean were responsible for vanquishing the evil entity even if indirectly. I’d appreciate refining it before I post it at Super Wiki.
Monster of the Week
On nine occasions someone or something other than Sam or Dean have vanquished the MoTW
* Spirit of Peter Sweeney (1.03)
* Poltergeist (1.09)
* Pagan God (1.11)
* Max Miller (1.14)
* Pa Bender (1.15)
* Vampires Hank and Luthor (1.20)
* Ansem Weems (2.05)
* Detective Sheridan (2.07)
* Walter Dixon (2.18)
On two occasions the MoTW vanished (the bugs in Bugs and the demon virus in Croatoan). Meg and the daevas are avoided rather than defeated in Shadows.
On two occasions the MoTW gets away unscathed - the Trickster in Tall Tales, and Maggie in Playthings.
Who killed what?
Dean has been responsible for vanquishing 23 supernatural things and Sam for eleven.
Four spirits have been vanquished through salting and burning and there have been four exorcisms.
Dean gets violent on fourteen occasions - shooting (wendigo, shapeshifter, striga, demon boy, Mr Tanner, Mrs Tanner, Nurse Pamela, Yellow-eyed Demon), stabbing (shapeshifter, Trickster double, Djinn), electrocuted (rawhead) and beheaded (vampire on two occassions).
Sam's three violent dispatches were by stabbing (rakshasa) and shooting (Madison, Jake). He also shot Angela the zombie although this didn’t kill her.
It is noteworthy that Sam has shot Dean on two occasions. ("Asylum" and "Born Under a Bad Sign").
Ep. When What How Who
1.01 Pilot Woman in White Shot but not killed Dean
Spirit of Constance Welch Banished after reunion with dead children Sam (he takes her home)
1.02 Wendigo Wendigo Flare gun Dean
1.03 Dead in the Water Spirit of Peter Sweeney Banished after all killers are dead Sheriff Jake Devins
1.04 Phantom Traveller Demon Exorcism Sam
1.05 Bloody Mary Bloody Mary Trapped in mirror that is broken Dean
1.06 Skin Shapeshifter Shot Dean
1.07 Hookman Hookman Banished by salting, burning and melting silver from his hook Dean
1.08 Bugs Possessed bugs Time passes Time
1.09 Home Poltergeist Defeated by stronger spirit Mary
1.10 Asylum Dr Ellicot’s spirit Salt and burn Dean
1.11 Scarecrow Pagan god Sacred tree is burnt Emily
1.12 Faith Rawhead Electrocution Dean
Sue Ann Le Grange Reaper, after it’s released from her control Sam
1.13 Route 666 Possessed truck Passes over hallowed ground Dean and Sam
1.14 Nightmare Max Miller Suicide Max
1.15 The Benders Pa Bender Shot Kathryn
1.16 Shadow Meg/Daveas Escaped from rather than defeated
1.17 Hell House Talpa manifesting as Mordecai House burnt Dean
1.18 Something Wicked Striga Shot Dean
1.19 Provenance Melanie Merchant Salt and burn Dean
1.20 Dead Man’s Blood Vamps Shot with crossbows Sam/Dean/John
Vamp!Hank Beheaded John
Vamp!Luthor Shot with Colt John
Vamp!Random Beheaded Dean
1.21 Salvation
1.22 Devil’s Trap Meg Exorcism Sam
Demon boy Shot with Colt Dean
2.01 In My Time of Dying John Bargain with Demon John/Demon
2.02 Everybody Loves a Clown Rakshasa Stabbed with brass pipe Sam
2.03 Bloodlust Vampire Beheaded Dean
2.04 Children shouldn’t Play with Dead Things Zombie Shot Dean
Shot Sam
Stabbed Dean
2.05 Simon Said Anson Shot Andy
2.06 No Exit Spirit of H.H. Holmes Trapped Sam/Dean/Jo
2.07 The Usual Suspects Detective Sheridan Shot Detective Ballard
2.08 Crossroad Blues Demon Bargain Dean
2.09 Croatoan Mr Tanner Shot Dean
Nurse Pamela Shot Dean
Mrs Tanner Shot Dean
Demon virus Disappears
2.10 Hunted Gordon Imprisoned Sam
2.11 Playthings Maggie A win for the vengeful spirit
2.12 Nightshifter Shapeshifter Stabbed Dean
2.13 Houses of the Holy Spirit of Father Gregory Exorcism Sam
2.14 Born Under a Bad Sign Meg!Demon Exorcism Bobby
2.15 Tall Tales Trickster Stabbed (although it is a double not the real Trickster) Dean
2.16 Roadkill Jonah Greely Salt and burn Sam
2.17 Heart Madison Shot with silver bullet Sam
2.18 Hollywood Babylon Walter Dixon Ripped apart Ghosts
2.19 Folsom Prison Blues Spirit of Nurse Glockner Salt and Burn Sam/Dean
2.20 What is and What Should Never Be Djinn Stabs Dean
2.21 All Hell Breaks Loose: Part One Sam Stabbed Jake
2.22 All Hell Breaks Loose: Part Two Jake Shot Sam
Yellow-Eyed Demon Shot with Colt Dean
This is not a definitive science so feel free to dispute my classifications or add ones I’ve missed. In some cases you could argue that Sam and/or Dean were responsible for vanquishing the evil entity even if indirectly. I’d appreciate refining it before I post it at Super Wiki.
Monster of the Week
On nine occasions someone or something other than Sam or Dean have vanquished the MoTW
* Spirit of Peter Sweeney (1.03)
* Poltergeist (1.09)
* Pagan God (1.11)
* Max Miller (1.14)
* Pa Bender (1.15)
* Vampires Hank and Luthor (1.20)
* Ansem Weems (2.05)
* Detective Sheridan (2.07)
* Walter Dixon (2.18)
On two occasions the MoTW vanished (the bugs in Bugs and the demon virus in Croatoan). Meg and the daevas are avoided rather than defeated in Shadows.
On two occasions the MoTW gets away unscathed - the Trickster in Tall Tales, and Maggie in Playthings.
Who killed what?
Dean has been responsible for vanquishing 23 supernatural things and Sam for eleven.
Four spirits have been vanquished through salting and burning and there have been four exorcisms.
Dean gets violent on fourteen occasions - shooting (wendigo, shapeshifter, striga, demon boy, Mr Tanner, Mrs Tanner, Nurse Pamela, Yellow-eyed Demon), stabbing (shapeshifter, Trickster double, Djinn), electrocuted (rawhead) and beheaded (vampire on two occassions).
Sam's three violent dispatches were by stabbing (rakshasa) and shooting (Madison, Jake). He also shot Angela the zombie although this didn’t kill her.
It is noteworthy that Sam has shot Dean on two occasions. ("Asylum" and "Born Under a Bad Sign").
Ep. When What How Who
1.01 Pilot Woman in White Shot but not killed Dean
Spirit of Constance Welch Banished after reunion with dead children Sam (he takes her home)
1.02 Wendigo Wendigo Flare gun Dean
1.03 Dead in the Water Spirit of Peter Sweeney Banished after all killers are dead Sheriff Jake Devins
1.04 Phantom Traveller Demon Exorcism Sam
1.05 Bloody Mary Bloody Mary Trapped in mirror that is broken Dean
1.06 Skin Shapeshifter Shot Dean
1.07 Hookman Hookman Banished by salting, burning and melting silver from his hook Dean
1.08 Bugs Possessed bugs Time passes Time
1.09 Home Poltergeist Defeated by stronger spirit Mary
1.10 Asylum Dr Ellicot’s spirit Salt and burn Dean
1.11 Scarecrow Pagan god Sacred tree is burnt Emily
1.12 Faith Rawhead Electrocution Dean
Sue Ann Le Grange Reaper, after it’s released from her control Sam
1.13 Route 666 Possessed truck Passes over hallowed ground Dean and Sam
1.14 Nightmare Max Miller Suicide Max
1.15 The Benders Pa Bender Shot Kathryn
1.16 Shadow Meg/Daveas Escaped from rather than defeated
1.17 Hell House Talpa manifesting as Mordecai House burnt Dean
1.18 Something Wicked Striga Shot Dean
1.19 Provenance Melanie Merchant Salt and burn Dean
1.20 Dead Man’s Blood Vamps Shot with crossbows Sam/Dean/John
Vamp!Hank Beheaded John
Vamp!Luthor Shot with Colt John
Vamp!Random Beheaded Dean
1.21 Salvation
1.22 Devil’s Trap Meg Exorcism Sam
Demon boy Shot with Colt Dean
2.01 In My Time of Dying John Bargain with Demon John/Demon
2.02 Everybody Loves a Clown Rakshasa Stabbed with brass pipe Sam
2.03 Bloodlust Vampire Beheaded Dean
2.04 Children shouldn’t Play with Dead Things Zombie Shot Dean
Shot Sam
Stabbed Dean
2.05 Simon Said Anson Shot Andy
2.06 No Exit Spirit of H.H. Holmes Trapped Sam/Dean/Jo
2.07 The Usual Suspects Detective Sheridan Shot Detective Ballard
2.08 Crossroad Blues Demon Bargain Dean
2.09 Croatoan Mr Tanner Shot Dean
Nurse Pamela Shot Dean
Mrs Tanner Shot Dean
Demon virus Disappears
2.10 Hunted Gordon Imprisoned Sam
2.11 Playthings Maggie A win for the vengeful spirit
2.12 Nightshifter Shapeshifter Stabbed Dean
2.13 Houses of the Holy Spirit of Father Gregory Exorcism Sam
2.14 Born Under a Bad Sign Meg!Demon Exorcism Bobby
2.15 Tall Tales Trickster Stabbed (although it is a double not the real Trickster) Dean
2.16 Roadkill Jonah Greely Salt and burn Sam
2.17 Heart Madison Shot with silver bullet Sam
2.18 Hollywood Babylon Walter Dixon Ripped apart Ghosts
2.19 Folsom Prison Blues Spirit of Nurse Glockner Salt and Burn Sam/Dean
2.20 What is and What Should Never Be Djinn Stabs Dean
2.21 All Hell Breaks Loose: Part One Sam Stabbed Jake
2.22 All Hell Breaks Loose: Part Two Jake Shot Sam
Yellow-Eyed Demon Shot with Colt Dean